re: Buying the lady a Coach bag for Christmas...is this garbage brand? Know nothing

Coming from a female here...I do agree with the others that Coach is now past its prime and is seen as a brand everyone can afford, therefore making it less desirable. Once the outlet opened at Tanger, the appeal wore off quickly after. I personally hate any bag that has a logo plastered all over it. Kate Spade is a safer choice and you can often find a 20% off full price coupon.

With that being said, if I had to pick from those four I would go top left where the logo is much more subtle.

ETA: I realize the way I worded that sounds snobby - didn't mean it that way. I'm just stating what the public opinion is now. It's part of my job to analyze trends and what makes things popular or not. Also...