re: Rank these NFL QB's in order on who you would want to start in a big game.

1) Roethlisberger - He is the best combination among this bunch. Still young, prime-ish, but still competing at a super high level. Guy is tough and gets it done, bottom line.
2) Brees - Most accurate QB in NFL History, and one of the most competitive. Behind maybe only Brady in this era in that regard. He gets it done, too.
3) Luck - he has a turnover problem, probably even more-so than Brees, but the guy wins in big games pretty often it seems. The biggest comeback in playoff history can't be ignored.
4) Rivers - Hasn't done it in big games but I take him over the slouches below
5) Newton - He has potential to move up pending this playoff season. He is proving to be a winner but statistically still isn't there and hasn't really won any big games yet in his career.
6) Ryan - It turns out he can't win much when the real Matty Ice (Bryant) isn't performing. What a surprise.
7) Wilson - Don't trust his ability to win without a defense, he is 2-15 when his defense gives up 23 or more. Since I don't know the scenario of your "big game," he falls hard.
8) Cutler - Pick 6, anyone?
9) Stafford - lol