Started By
Message

re: in retrospect, Cars is not the shitshow the MTV Board argues

Posted on 10/7/15 at 3:34 pm to
Posted by OMLandshark
Member since Apr 2009
110063 posts
Posted on 10/7/15 at 3:34 pm to
quote:

Toy Story was about toys. Not toys acting like humans. Just Toys. How they relate to humanity, to growing up. Etc. Toy Story is way more thoughtful than Cars.


Toy Story is so great because the universe is incredibly layered and incredibly terrifying when you think about it. Toy Story 1 didn't even crack surface, with only going after a kid who loves blowing up his toys. These toys Gods are children, Gods that will certainly abandon them at some point, and that creates quite a fricked up little world about a group that is doomed to be left for dead in a landfill.

Cars is just that: Cars acting like humans. It's ridiculous and requires almost no creativity besides car puns. That's all these movies can be boiled down to. It is not important at all in the Cars franchise that they are cars. You wouldn't change the plot at all just by making them humans. Can't say the same with Toy Story, Inside Out, Wall-e, or Ratatouille when it comes to their respected universes. These movies tell us about the light and dark sides of nature that we take for granted, and everyone can relate to them. Not so much with Cars.
Posted by MrTide33
Member since Nov 2012
4353 posts
Posted on 10/7/15 at 3:44 pm to
quote:

It's ok for the TRex to be an idiot, b/c we dont' know who it is, but we dont' like the fact that Mater is an idiot b/c it's Larry the Cable Guy. That's what I gathered from that review.


The review was saying that the big, bad t-rex being a nasally neurotic wimp is funny because it's not what's expected. On the other hand, a rusty tow truck being a dumb redneck is exactly what you'd expect.

quote:

It is not important at all in the Cars franchise that they are cars. You wouldn't change the plot at all just by making them humans.


That's true, and it's compounded by the fact that if it was humans instead of cars, it would basically fit the Hallmark movie formula.
Posted by TeddyPadillac
Member since Dec 2010
26038 posts
Posted on 10/7/15 at 3:54 pm to
quote:

Toy Story is so great because the universe is incredibly layered and incredibly terrifying when you think about it. Toy Story 1 didn't even crack surface, with only going after a kid who loves blowing up his toys. These toys Gods are children, Gods that will certainly abandon them at some point, and that creates quite a fricked up little world about a group that is doomed to be left for dead in a landfill.



Nothing close to resembling this has ever crossed the mind of any kid while watching Toy Story. They are thinking wouldn't it be cool if my toys could come to life, like in Doc McStuffins.

quote:

It's ridiculous and requires almost no creativity besides car puns.

in your opinion.

quote:

It is not important at all in the Cars franchise that they are cars.

Why does this matter?
It's not important that Simba is a lion. Where's the bitching for that murderous movie that was given a 1 seed if i recall correctly. Did we really need minions? we couldn't just use midgets like on Willy Wonka? Why did Nemo have to be a fish? they could have all been humans and told the same exact story? Why did they have the little gnomes in Frozen? could have just been humans.

quote:

These movies tell us about the light and dark sides of nature that we take for granted, and everyone can relate to them. Not so much with Cars.


Everyone except kids, b/c they aren't thinking that deep about this kids movie.
So you don't think Cars told a story that kids can relate to? you think it was just cars acting like humans and pointless?
Cars is simple. It's a funny movie that centers around friendship. There's no deep thoughts needed. It shows us that we can be friends with people that may seem different at first or have different interest, once we get to know them. That is something every kid experiences many times in life, as well as adults.
Posted by Indigold
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2013
1703 posts
Posted on 10/7/15 at 3:57 pm to
quote:

Cars is just that: Cars acting like humans. It's ridiculous and requires almost no creativity besides car puns. That's all these movies can be boiled down to. It is not important at all in the Cars franchise that they are cars. You wouldn't change the plot at all just by making them humans


Exactly (didn't see this before I sent the above post)
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram