When you have to use selective stats to make your case, then you've already lost the argument. Why leave out Jeffersons stats vs UGA and Bama II for 2011? Both are SEC teams, right?

Below are Jeffersons 2011 stats. They were worse than both his 2009, and 2010 stats, and includes a cupcake game against WKU. Lee's 2011 stats were much better than 2009, and 2010. He was named to ESPNs Sr all-SEC team for Christ sake. Over Jefferson! Forgive me if I take ESPN's word over yours

quote:
2011 61/100 61.0% 737 yards 81.9 avg 6 TD 2 int 138.71 QB rat

Lee improved over 4 years, JJ did not

2 ...

Report Post

Posted by BCS Statmaster

Member since Jan 2007

1552 posts

Posted on 8/3/15 at 4:21 am to League Champs

quote:
Jefferson's performance, like very other QB under Miles, improved from his initial year to his last.

SEC Regular Season Games

quote:
When you have to use selective stats to make your case, then you've already lost the argument. Why leave out Jeffersons stats vs UGA and Bama II for 2011? Both are SEC teams, right?

quote:
Lee improved over 4 years, JJ did not

Previously discussed within this thread AD ABSURDUM (pages 27-29) ... arbitrary selection, application/exclusion of 'outliers' without consistency or mathematical justification, etc.

Bottom line ... the games never happened ... Voo Doo disguised as pseudo science.

Salviati claims to have graduated 'twice' from LSU. Obviously the first one didn't count.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by Salviati

Member since Apr 2006

5602 posts

Posted on 8/3/15 at 8:06 am to League Champs

quote:

When you have to use selective stats to make your case, then you've already lost the argument. Why leave out Jeffersons stats vs UGA and Bama II for 2011? Both are SEC teams, right?

I've explained REPEATEDLY why the SECCG and the BCSSCG were properly excluded from the comparison.

quote:
Below are Jeffersons 2011 stats. They were worse than both his 2009, and 2010 stats, and includes a cupcake game against WKU.

Cupcake games? Lee started against the biggest cupcake of the them all in 2011. And Lee started against 4 of the 5 biggest cupcakes. In 2011, Lee had seven passes against a Top 5 Defense. Two of those seven passes were intercepted.

quote:
Lee was named to ESPNs Sr all-SEC team for Christ sake. Over Jefferson! Forgive me if I take ESPN's word over yours

Jefferson missed the first four games, and did not start until Lee got yanked in the GOTC. Thus, according to ESPN, Jefferson did not have enough starting games to qualify for the award.