re: Asiata and Mckinnon, discussion on worth

quote:

---

He's too dynamic to not play at this point. Asiata just isnt good enough to carry them 100%.

---

I agree with this sentiment. However, where do you place him? I would hold him over a second qb.

I would stash him over a bench player replacement.

He is high risk, high reward type of player. I wouldn't drop Hyde for him. I am not dropping Hilton, Cooks, or Hunter.

Given only two bench spots, it gets tricky. I think holding 3 and 4 rbs and wrs are good. That way you have an injury replacement if needed.

So, West is rather needed this week. I love getting someone for long term upside, but I think West is going to get points. Now one could say that Hunter is likely to get some points. Maybe enough to hold you over. West is likely a short term player at this point. Hell, if they have Crowell vulture again, West is unlikely to be much better than Hill or Hyde.

Hill is a solid back. He is that inside running threat that the bengals can use. He could be vulturing tds in the future. He could be used in the passing game as well.

So, its between west, Hill, and Mckinnon. I hold onto two. who do I cut?