re: Milk Bar for lunch. What should I get?

butcher has tons more atmosphere than Milk Bar.

and while we're comparing the two I'll say that I think MB does better sandwiches. Butcher is decent, but usually the sandwiches are very very greasy. I get that it's supposed to be decadent and indulgent and they use lots of fatty meats, sauces, etc.. but when the bread is completely soaked through with grease you're trying too hard.