re: Mature whitetail with one side of antlers "deformed", what would you do?

I put quotations around the word "missing" because I didn't know how else to word it in the title. I have always called these types of deer "fonky horn" deer. I explained in the first post that it appeared to be a vertical point, which to me indicates that it wasn't broken off.

If this would have been on public land, I would have given it more thought. I never really considered harvesting the deer because there is a good chance he has great genetics. This would have been the biggest deer I ever killed if it was anything remotely close to symmetrical.