re: Crackpot ASOIAF Theories SPOILERS

quote:

---

So does that mean since Ice was the Stark weapon that they are descended from AA?

---

i've been thinking this could be a possibility

if AA once stood up to the Others, then its likely that AA was one of the First Men since the First Men and the CotF fought the Others together

If AA was one of the first men, its possible that a Stark was AA, but was only called AA by the followers of R'hllor

but i dont think Valryian steel was in Westeros at the time of that war, so its probably not ICe

but i still think AA was one of the old Starks