Are these the same deer?

I'll let you work on that a little bit before I answer

deer in the first pic appears to only have 9pts deer on the right in second pic is clearly a 10pt unless you are referring to the deer on left in second pic.

Same deer. Definitely not 140. 120-125... Depending on the circumstances, I'd let him walk. Depends on if you hunt with people that like to shoot. I hunt one place with a group of people that would most definitely wax that, so I would be trying to beat them to the punch... If you are lucky enough to hunt the place by yourself, or if can let him go and not regret it, he'll be bumping 150 next year.