Coaching Question

yes

So if Miles wasn't our coach you are assuming we would have had a better record with anybody as head coach. I agree?

Looty would have won us at least one more game than Miles?

I hate this thread and FML

No idea.

But I do believe we should have won the NC in 2006.

quote:

---

Do you think if Saban wasn't our coach in 2004 we would have done better or worse than 8-5?

---

LSU was 9-3 in 2004.

quote:

---

Do yall think we wouldn't have won the NC in 2007 if Miles wasn't our coach?

---

This question makes my hair hurt ... isn't that a double negative? So in reality, you're asking if LSU would have won the 2007 NC if Miles WAS our coach? Since he was our coach, the answer is clearly "yes".

If you're asking whether LSU would have won the 2007 NC if someone else were our coach, the answer is "it depends". Without Miles in 2007, we likely lose to UF (who else would have gone for all of those 4th downs?). However, we probably beat UK ... not sure about Arky.

quote:

---

Meant 2002.

---

LSU was 6-1 until Mauck got hurt.

quote:

---

But OK, since we're likely to go 9-3 this year and people are acting like we need to fire everyone associated with coaching LSU, I'll ask "Do you think if Saban wasn't our coach in 2004 we would have done better or worse than 9-3?" Because 9-3 = FAIL, right?

---

9-3 is not fail, but 9-2 was a slight disappointment only because we just won the NC. But Mauck elected to go pro/dental school and Clayton to NFL. 9-2 was what it was. The last loss, of course, Saban never should have been allowed to coach - thanks Stanley Bertman. We win with any other coach because Saban was already coaching the Dolphins.