re: American Nightmare — Netflix documentary

quote:

---

And they never cleared up why Andrea was the target. Only because Muller didn’t say?

---

Little late to the thread but just watched this.

Muller lived on the island at one point. Near the victims home. The college kids knew him as the peeping tom or "creeper" and said he was ex military.

Muller obviously knew the fiance and Aaron from his time living on the Island.
Muller later moved to the wooded area, you see in the doc, and went back to the island to kidnap Aaron's fiance but they had already split up, unbeknownst to Muller, so he took Denise instead.

The fact that they never looked into the other, allegedly kidnappers is insane but par for the course for this case. Muller says they were college friends and ex marines. Now wether they actually existed or Muller made the whole thing up to rape Denise again we may never know.