re: Caribbean Destination Family of 4

First you need to decide what you wanna do. Beach all day and enjoy resort or an island that has excursions. There are some places like Turks and Caicos with beautiful beaches but not much else outside of the resort and water activities. Or you could go St Lucia with mountains and hiking and golf and such. Several options in between. Do you want a resort or an air bnb type house where you might need to get groceries and such. Depending on your style that would narrow down your options.

Atlantis is nice but very touristy and crowded. It’s not a relaxing vacation in my opinion.