Started By
Message

re: Thermometers are racist

Posted on 9/8/22 at 4:36 pm to
Posted by luvdoc
"Please Ignore Our Yelp Reviews"
Member since May 2005
923 posts
Posted on 9/8/22 at 4:36 pm to
OP is histrionic. This press release from Emory makes no claim of racism.

Someone set out to answer a reasonable question, whether skin pigment can interfere with accurate temperature measurements. They found it did do so.

For each patient, the first pair of oral and temporal temperatures measured within one hour of each other were recorded within the first day of hospitalization. The researchers found a 26 percent lower odds of detecting fevers in Black patients using temporal compared to oral thermometers. 

However. . .

The researchers note that although the absolute difference between oral and temporal temperatures was small, this discrepancy combined with commonly used fever cut-offs can lead to fevers going undetected in many Black patients.

So the difference was "small", but "can" result in "many" errors for dark-skinned people

Okay, so surely the next paragraph is going to answer the obvious question: what were the actual error rates for blacks, whites, and all comers?

That Crucial Information is never provided in the article.

26% sounds like a lot, but if the absolute accuracy is medically adequate with low melanin, 26% worse is not likely to cross a threshold into grossly inadequate for those with darker skin.

If four out of 10,000 light skinned patients get an error with the temporal scanner, then 26% worse is only five out of 10,000 with darker pigment.

And if it was four verses five out of every 10 patients, I wouldn't want the Temporal Scanner no matter what color I was.

So naturally, the press release does not provide The actual data/information that would allow a reader to draw any useful conclusions.

Instead, it seems purposefully oblique in presenting info to the reader, intending to induce a superficial and emotional response to the obvious, inherent injustice, devoid of data, rather than dispassionately relaying the outcome of a thoughtfully performed study designed to answer an appropriate and apolitical question.

Or so I assume, I didn't actually look at the publication that the press release references. One would hope a more professional tone was struck.

But this press release is deserving of scorn on many levels. Similar in scope to "Thermometers are racist"
This post was edited on 9/8/22 at 5:05 pm
Posted by dgnx6
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
68941 posts
Posted on 9/8/22 at 5:04 pm to
quote:

But this press release is deserving of scorn on many levels. Similar in scope to "Thermometers are racist"



First i believe the op is just joking because someone paid for this study.

And i also noticed when looking for some data nothing was given to me to come to some serious conclusions, just shoulds and coulds.

Posted by Amadeo
Member since Jan 2004
4826 posts
Posted on 9/8/22 at 5:29 pm to
quote:

OP is histrionic. This press release from Emory makes no claim of racism.

Maybe so, but it did offer an excuse for the author of the article to indulge his or her's little "woke itch" by applying the AP standard of capitalizing the adjective black and keeping White in lower case.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram