Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

Hillbilly Elegy

Posted on 8/1/17 at 11:53 am
Posted by John Gotti
Vestavia HIlls, AL
Member since Jul 2013
3370 posts
Posted on 8/1/17 at 11:53 am
Anyone read this? I've heard three different people (my priest, a political commentator and an attorney friend) talk about it lately but haven't really talked to them about it - they just mentioned they had read it. Considered buying it today but I have a few books in the hopper. For those that have read it - should I pull the trigger?
Posted by Wasp
Off Highland rd.
Member since Sep 2012
1483 posts
Posted on 8/1/17 at 7:24 pm to
I read it a few months ago. I enjoyed it but it was right up my alley. A general summary is that it is biographical about his hillbilly childhood and the effect that it has on his professional career. What makes it good is that while it is about hillbillies, it could really be about any fringe group within society.
Posted by The Spleen
Member since Dec 2010
38865 posts
Posted on 8/2/17 at 8:01 am to
I only read about half of it. It came across a bit sanctimonious to me. Felt like he was just parroting the same old "poor is a choice" mantra that often ignores real life struggles many poor people face on a daily basis. Maybe it got better in the 2nd half of the book, but that was my impression of it.
Posted by Chili Davis
Wichita, KS
Member since Nov 2010
815 posts
Posted on 8/2/17 at 11:18 am to
The first part is pretty sanctimonious. Although I think he was right about a lot of what he was talking about with the kid in the flooring store.

It's a fairly entertaining book. I could have interchanged some of his family with some of my relatives.

Overall, pretty interesting book and an easy read.
Posted by studentsect
Member since Jan 2004
2258 posts
Posted on 8/2/17 at 11:35 am to
Worth reading, but I don't think it's worthy of all of the praise it's received.

It is an interesting window into Vance's life and why it sucks to be small-town poor, but it does not really provide any solutions to the problems identified.

I think a lot of readers who grew up wealthy in bigger cities found it eye-opening...I grew up in a shitty small town and Hillbilly Elegy didn't really add anything to what I already knew about the lives of poor people in small towns (to clarify, my family was not poor and my personal experiences weren't anything like Vance's, I'm just referring to my general awareness of what was happening to people around town).

Edit: Agree with the poster above about being able to interchange some of his family with some of my relatives; that's why I found it enjoyable, but not really impactful/transformative/etc.
This post was edited on 8/2/17 at 11:38 am
Posted by OldTigahFot
Drinkin' with the rocket scientists
Member since Jan 2012
10500 posts
Posted on 8/2/17 at 9:54 pm to
quote:

What makes it good is that while it is about hillbillies, it could really be about any fringe group within society.


This was what I gathered from it also. I found the book entertaining but not earth-shattering.
Posted by dirtsandwich
AL
Member since May 2016
5125 posts
Posted on 8/3/17 at 6:39 am to
Just bought it. About to start. Am certain I will be able to relate to some of it.
Posted by FootballNostradamus
Member since Nov 2009
20509 posts
Posted on 8/16/17 at 12:17 am to
quote:

Worth reading, but I don't think it's worthy of all of the praise it's received.


This.

It's getting a bit too much praise, but it's quick, entertaining, and somewhat enlightening in parts.

His Grandmaw is one crazy as mofo .
Posted by jackwoods4
Member since Sep 2013
28667 posts
Posted on 8/17/17 at 12:28 pm to
Just met up with somebody and they were telling me to check it out.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram