Favorite team:LSU 
Location:Charleston, SC
Biography:Reauxll Tide
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:5610
Registered on:10/25/2009
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
The things that so frustrating with Baker is statistically he will put a good defense on the field and it will play well and keep you in almost any game 95% of the time… but you just know when you need that IT and CLUTCH moment it just isn’t going to happen.
quote:

The 3 QBs we have right now may be the worst we've had in 40 years.


Ummmm no
Our game best not be effected in any way with tv times because of this. Because I could see this little charade by Ole Miss being so delulu and spiteful of us playing at night they would be moronic enough to plea to Stankey take the night game from us even though it would mean they now have to play at night away. That would be very hang the west cochamp level petty and taking something away from us is a victory for the day since there gonna lose to OU whenever they end up playing.
If you said statistically where each individual unit is ranked I think every Tiger fan would take it and not expect the overall record going along with it. It’s the magic of those defining moments that is missing imo. Being 0-2 in the big ones so far give valid reason to worry about the next two with a lot hanging on them. Beat Texas and Tenn and the season has a lot different taste than losing both of them.
quote:

The copilot was severely panicking (obvious reason being they were plummeting to the earth in a likely irrecoverable dive) and trying to get the pilot to properly reorient the plane in anyway possible. She could have been trying to get him to orient himself using the horizon assuming at the point they were out of the clouds.


Agree with all this! The most shocking thing of the audio was the relative calm after the big scream clearly telling ATC the status of the plane. And then the final call where it’s holy shite this is really it.
quote:

This has to be the dumbest justification for her flying at her age that I’ve seen going around social media.


I’ve had a 60 year old Capt texting his wife middle of a true ILS in the soup that I was pilot flying as FO and when I noticed made the comment am I flying this jet single pilot right now… and then ripped him some more once parked at the FBO like wtf was that important it couldn’t wait 5 minutes… now all the armchair pilots mid ILS vs at a cruise altitude of 35000 ft to fire off a text are vastly different things
quote:

Hurricane hunters are usually flying at much lower altitudes.


Which is usually more dangerous fyi
quote:

by UpToPar Alright, for those that a much more knowledgeable about this stuff than I am, explain why flying into an intense storm cell causes catastrophic failure here, but hurricane hunters can fly through the eye wall of a cat 5 hurricane and be fine. I'm sure those hurricane hunter planes are better equipped for the conditions, but what is it about those planes that allows them to withstand severe weather?


Hurricanes actually have very steady lateral winds as opposed to this being more up drafts and down drafts in a rapidly building cumulonimbus event. Now the eye wall and all that yes has the up and down drafts but you aren’t flying a T tail bird into it I will also say. I have taken a Lear off in a Cat 1 before. We delayed departure by about 3 hours as the storm came on shore so the winds were right down the pipe of the runway for takeoff. One airborne it was smooth as a baby’s bottom.
quote:

Noted. I'm not sure if you can make an apples to apples comparison with what a surgeon does, though.


I can tell you when I got a jam playing vibing with the gusty cross wind I’ll land better. But I can only do that with friends flying to the keys in a rented Piper Seminole, vs an airliner with 240 people behind me.
quote:

I don't agree with the music part, but the rest will be conveniently ignored by the armchair pilots in here.


Bluetooth music into my Bose aviation headset isn’t allowed while I’m flying 121 ops fwiw.


The side step east on my flight last night dealing with the same system was only because one bolt of lightning showed itself and lit the clouds up. Granted I was coming in after dark not that not seeing shite pitch black vs soupy white makes a difference in not being able to see shite. The onboard radar had everything painted green and smooth sailing. Granted I’m flirting with yellow returns based on flight aware in the low 30s vs a super cell building up to 45000, there are times just go with your gut which takes experience especially when dealing with embedded shite.
quote:

The best shot they had at seeing the cell was on their on-board radar and if it was explosive development they likely wouldn’t have even been painting it on the screen before they flew into it.


Let’s not forget already getting radar returns off everything else weakening the beam for what was building in front of them at atleast 500 fpm
quote:

Why even make that part of the equation in the middle of thunderstorms? It's not like they were cruising along over Nebraska without a cloud in the sky.


Because how the family said the text came through sounds like that was fire off around the western coast where discussions were beginning to happen in that cockpit. As multiple of us have said why they went north is puzzling but it wasn’t a oh I’m too busy with my phone to pay attention. I highly doubt from all the facts I’ve seen this “text” was sent in the middle of the storm when she’s telling ATC about precipitation, turbulence, icing, etc. asking for a higher altitude. I know for me last night with the more advanced radar on the A320 series I was scanning up and down manually telling the radar what altitude I wanted to look at vs just letting it do its auto return skirting the edge of the system out over the Atlantic planning my descent.
quote:

not much. and she might have been 100% locked in outside of that one quick text to her boyfriend. but if i'm making a list of people that i think would have a difficult time picking up their phone and sending one single text without doing a single other thing on that phone (just a quick glance at IG or Facebook!), i'm putting 20 year old girls pretty high up. i'm not trying to be combative with you at all. you've had some great contributions to this thread, and you could be entirely right. i just know that the text is a tickmark in the "distracted" column and not in the "locked-in" column.


Not taken combative at all. There just are time in the profession a text on the airplane computer to ops on how many fewer wheel chairs we are going to need deplaning than boarding and it’s just fine to fly the airplane at the same time. But the second you pick up a personal devise it’s why a plane went down and I’ll fight for my fellow pilots who are no longer here to defend themselves.


To pilots it’s our office and everyday life. A brain surgeon vibing to music in the OR is a distraction. A text is not going to distract you from an obvious red echo on the radar return is what I was mainly getting at there.

I agree when all shite hits the fan and tick marks tally up you’re right it’s not in her favor. But I guarantee if they had gone south more text probably would’ve be sent cruising through smoother clearer air ready to be having a pina colada on the beach in Eleuthera
quote:

there is obviously not a direct correlation between a text ten minutes prior and the plane flying into the ground. but it does speak to her mindset and raises questions about what else she was distracted by.


How much brain CPU % does it take yall to fire a text? If yall wanna peg this on her mindset go the young route, she wasn’t bold or confident enough to speak up and voice concern over the captain choosing to pick their way through it vs spend the 20 mins to fly an extra 200 miles to go around it totally? But we don’t know what those conversations even are yet. You could be totally right and the phone was more a distraction than I’m thinking it was. It could’ve been a quick 5 second turbulence is rough but managing it text shot off and right back discussing with the captain what to do. We just don’t know yet.
quote:

Not only that, this storm built up very quickly and likely didn't appear as dangerous as it was until it was too late.


This storm also has all the characteristics of an embedded cell in already IMC conditions. So in the soup already their eyeballs looking at it towering in front of them was not working in their favor either.
quote:

Alleged distraction in the cockpit isn't a fault moments before/as critical errors are made that lead to unrecoverable decent?


No. They made the decision and active turns. It’s not like they flew hundred of miles in a straight line from Texas not paying attention and just whoopsie into the cell. Text or no text decisions were being made in that cockpit. That’s the real question I have and why they decided that course vs going south, not they just accidentally ended up there being distracted by a text.
I’m trying to figure out why they went north too. Coming into Miami from the northeast I brought up to the capt I was flying with all this weather spinning in off the Atlantic as we get closer and see real time but maybe at the GA/SC border we head down the west coast of Florida and join up with the Vudoo arrival into soflo cause the Everglades are weather free
quote:

You're cool with a pilot in charge of 7 people's lives firing off text(s) moments before the aircraft she helping fly, navigates directly into a supercell. That's just a wild thing to be ok with. She should have been actively monitoring the weather radar that moments later got them killed.


To think a text changed this in any way is wild. The text didn’t make the decision to turn north and try to weave through it vs head south and avoid it entirely. If you’re looking for fault just to place blame somewhere before we even know all the facts that’s where to point, not the text.

LINK Mach tuck explained very simply
quote:

Huh? Shes in complete distress and screaming.


Of course who wouldn’t be… but she’s still able to relay accurate information to ATC, has her bearings to know what’s up and what’s down (something that has killed plenty of pilots not being able to do in far less extreme situations), and one of her screams is telling the captain to look outside as if trying to get him to get his bearings.