- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Score Board
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- SEC Score Board
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
| Favorite team: | Alabama |
| Location: | |
| Biography: | |
| Interests: | |
| Occupation: | |
| Number of Posts: | 3831 |
| Registered on: | 11/19/2015 |
| Online Status: | Not Online |
Recent Posts
Message
I’m cheering for LSU today. A good test of how strong rivalries are comparatively is who you would pick in a head to head marchup. I’d take LSU over UT, UT over Auburn, and Auburn over no one.
re: Tough decision to make
Posted by Decker on 11/21/26 at 12:07 pm to RTRnFlorida
If LSU wins, won’t Texas be ahead of us and we still don’t have to go?
Different doctors recommend different follow up times; it is hard for me to say definitively without all of your information or the imaging in front of me. But 3 months is kind of a standard follow up time for a chest finding that a physician thinks is borderline. For instance, if you have pneumonia, and your chest CT shows pneumonia but there is an area that kind of looks like a nodule or mass, I might recommend a 3 month follow up to make sure that area improves and isn't an underlying cancer. Things take time to heal, so shorter follow up might not show any change.
The reason most small nodule follow ups are 6 or 12 months is the nodules are likely benign, so we want to show long term stability to prove they are benign.
In your case, maybe the doctor thought the nodule size difference was significant and wanted a short term follow up (3 months) to make sure it isn't growing rapidly. I would have to look at everything myself to be certain, but going from 3 mm to 5 mm in a year to me in a non smoker is pretty insignificant; sometimes the measurements can simply be off that much without any actual change. If the nodule has changed in shape or density or now demonstrates suspicious characteristics, that would concern me more. Barring those changes, I do no think there is anything to worry about. But your doctor has all of the info so a follow up in 3 months won't hurt anything. If the nodule is stable then I would push for like one more follow up in a year and then forget about it.
The reason most small nodule follow ups are 6 or 12 months is the nodules are likely benign, so we want to show long term stability to prove they are benign.
In your case, maybe the doctor thought the nodule size difference was significant and wanted a short term follow up (3 months) to make sure it isn't growing rapidly. I would have to look at everything myself to be certain, but going from 3 mm to 5 mm in a year to me in a non smoker is pretty insignificant; sometimes the measurements can simply be off that much without any actual change. If the nodule has changed in shape or density or now demonstrates suspicious characteristics, that would concern me more. Barring those changes, I do no think there is anything to worry about. But your doctor has all of the info so a follow up in 3 months won't hurt anything. If the nodule is stable then I would push for like one more follow up in a year and then forget about it.
I've never seen a nodule under 6 mm in a non smoker grow into a primary lung cancer. If the patient has a different type of cancer already, a small lung nodule could represent metastatic disease, but that is a different scenario.
Primary lung cancers do happen in non smokers and, yes, they do have to start somewhere. But the odds of finding them when they are that small are really low, and the overwhelming majority of nodules that size are benign. It is just a matter of statistics. Statistically, that nodule in your lung is benign and a risk-benefit analysis would conclude that no further imaging is needed.
We do this in all fields of medicine - any small abnormality could possible represent something serious, but we have to determine what is worth working up and what is better left alone.
Primary lung cancers do happen in non smokers and, yes, they do have to start somewhere. But the odds of finding them when they are that small are really low, and the overwhelming majority of nodules that size are benign. It is just a matter of statistics. Statistically, that nodule in your lung is benign and a risk-benefit analysis would conclude that no further imaging is needed.
We do this in all fields of medicine - any small abnormality could possible represent something serious, but we have to determine what is worth working up and what is better left alone.
A nodule under 6 mm in a non smoker is extremely unlikely to be cancer. If I could see the nodule I could be even more sure but my opinion is based on national guidelines and personal experience. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a nodule that small turn into cancer in a non smoker in 15 years of working.
Usually like 20-30 pack year history so you are well short of that.
If the nodule is calcified it is basically 100% benign in your case and never needs to be imaged again.
If it isn’t calcified, 6 mm is the cutoff, so a follow up in 6-12 months is reasonable.
If the nodule is calcified it is basically 100% benign in your case and never needs to be imaged again.
If it isn’t calcified, 6 mm is the cutoff, so a follow up in 6-12 months is reasonable.
re: Found a new nodule during my CT today
Posted by Decker on 11/14/26 at 11:09 am to Upperdecker
I have often thought about doing like a Q and A thing on here from time to time because I recognize how difficult it can be for patients to get straight answers. I have always prided myself on trying to inform patients, friends, family, etc as much as possible. As a radiologist, I don't have as much patient contact but I see the entire scope of medicine and I can answer most imaging questions. Most of my friends call me or text me when they have imaging and I look at it and go over it with them.
In this case, OP has nothing to worry about. I can say that confidently as an expert in this field who reads these studies every day. Not neccessarily in this case, but I do notice that sometimes when people have incidental findings (pulmonary nodules, thyroid nodules, breast cysts, adrenal nodules, etc) that are benign they are a little reluctant to accept a benign diagnosis and almost seem to be hoping for something more serious. I often have to tell people, "this lesion is benign, you never need to worry about it again, and this is the best possible news."
In this case, OP has nothing to worry about. I can say that confidently as an expert in this field who reads these studies every day. Not neccessarily in this case, but I do notice that sometimes when people have incidental findings (pulmonary nodules, thyroid nodules, breast cysts, adrenal nodules, etc) that are benign they are a little reluctant to accept a benign diagnosis and almost seem to be hoping for something more serious. I often have to tell people, "this lesion is benign, you never need to worry about it again, and this is the best possible news."
There is almost a zero chance these nodules are cancer. You don’t really need to keep having scans for them unless it helps you sleep better at night. Plus, CT scans slightly increase your lifetime risk of cancer because of radiation exposure.
Still likely insignificant. How old are you? Why did they scan your lungs in the first place? Most nodules under 1 cm are incidental, benign, and insignificant. The Fleischner society recommendation for a non smoker with nodules less than 6 mm is no follow up at all. You can google Fleischner society recommendations for pulmonary nodules; they are pretty much the universal guidelines.
Radiologist here - overwhelming likelihood is these are nothing to worry about. Really only two exceptions - if you already have a history of cancer and there is concern it has spread to the lungs (which doesn’t seem like the case) or you have a significant smoking history (in which case these nodules are still small enough that a one year follow up would be recommended). If you don’t have a history of cancer or a significant smoking history, you can pretty much ignore these.
If you take away all the times we beat y’all, y’all are dominating the series
One Battle After Another
I have really enjoyed most of PTA’s movies and this one won all of the awards, so I was incredibly disappointed by how terrible it was. Just a bad movie made worse by the unwarranted hype.
I have really enjoyed most of PTA’s movies and this one won all of the awards, so I was incredibly disappointed by how terrible it was. Just a bad movie made worse by the unwarranted hype.
I was bitten by a pygmy rattlesnake in high school. Spent several hours in the ER but they determined it wasn’t going to kill me so I didn’t receive anti-venom.
re: Songs about Alabama. Nominations and ranking.
Posted by Decker on 4/19/26 at 11:05 pm to Harry Rex Vonner
That Western Skyline - Dawes
Birmingham - Shovels & Rope
Birmingham - Randy Newman
Birmingham - Ryan Adams
Oporto-Madrid Blvd - St. Paul and the Broken Bones
Alabama Rain - Jim Croce
Alabama Hightest - Old Crow Medicine Show
Birmingham - Shovels & Rope
Birmingham - Randy Newman
Birmingham - Ryan Adams
Oporto-Madrid Blvd - St. Paul and the Broken Bones
Alabama Rain - Jim Croce
Alabama Hightest - Old Crow Medicine Show
Believe it or not, I watched them back to back at a theater in Memphis when they came out. Daniel Day Lewis is amazing but No Country is the better movie.
This traffic around Baton Rouge sucks
These sound awesome but can you eat at these places or do you have to get it to go?
re: Lafayette dinner recommendations
Posted by Decker on 3/31/26 at 1:39 pm to shotskimakesmysat
What would you order at Fezzo’s?
Lafayette dinner recommendations
Posted by Decker on 3/31/26 at 12:29 pm
Driving through this evening on our way to Houston (for our Rice visit). Would love some dinner recommendations. The internet recommends Bon Temps, Prejean’s, Don’s, Fezzo’s (in Scott), and The Cajun Table.
Thanks for all of the replies. He has been offered a 50% tuition scholarship to Rice, so that would ease the pain a little. He is pretty much deciding between Rice and Alabama, although we will visit SMU next week as well.
Popular

0












