Started By
Message

re: Is overfishing of menhaden a threat to speckled trout? Louisiana Sportsman

Posted on 5/29/20 at 1:02 pm to
Posted by BayouTiger71
Pineville, LA
Member since Dec 2004
157 posts
Posted on 5/29/20 at 1:02 pm to
No, the menhaden industry is profitable because the entire fish is used and menhaden are very oily; two products are thus produced -- fish meal and fish oil. Unfortunately, freshwater carp are not oily.
Posted by BayouTiger71
Pineville, LA
Member since Dec 2004
157 posts
Posted on 5/29/20 at 1:10 pm to
I have spent hours compiling research on bycatch, stock assessments, sport fish forage, and am now about half way done. I bet $500 that I will complete my response after I return from vacation next week.

I emailed the online Louisiana Sportsman Magazine and requested that I be allowed to offer a rebuttal on their article. I never received a response, and my internet account cannot be accessed.

I may have to post my response here or send it to you through email. Are you still on for a bet?

BTW, the only good thing that I can say about the University of Central Florida is that my wife is a graduate. She attended school there while I worked in Florida for a few years.

This post was edited on 5/29/20 at 1:46 pm
Posted by stewie
Member since Jan 2006
3951 posts
Posted on 5/29/20 at 1:57 pm to
quote:

I may have to post my response here or send it to you through email. Are you still on for a bet?


Let me get this straight, you want me to essentially pay you, a “marine biologist,” on an anonymous message board $500 to produce a “report” supporting the menhaden industry.
You have yet to produce any info other than your unsubstantiated credentials.

No name, no educational background, no other “report.”

No, I’m not going to take that “bet.”

However, I will meet you at the WLF headquarters on June 4th to listen and discuss the commercial menhaden Industry’s impact on Louisiana fisheries.

I’ll buy lunch and a beer after and we can discuss your findings.
Posted by BayouTiger71
Pineville, LA
Member since Dec 2004
157 posts
Posted on 5/29/20 at 2:32 pm to
I am a retired marine fisheries biologist and am no longer employed, and will not gain financially from my response. I only solicited a bet because of your sarcastic response. I do not blame you for not believing my qualifications because you cannot believe everything you read on an internet forum. If I knew your email I could send you my resume with my educational background, professional resume, volunteer work, and publication list.

I apologize for my offering to bet and also for the derogatory comment about UCF, although I did enjoy seeing LSU beat them in 2019. I appreciate your offer to talk and have lunch and a beer afterwards next Tuesday in Baton Rouge, and would be willing to do so in the future if you really are interested in my view point based upon scientific data and sound fisheries management. I do not live in Baton Rouge plus I will be out of state next week visiting relatives.

Are you attending the LDWF Commission meeting because of the report on the gulf menhaden fishery?
This post was edited on 5/29/20 at 2:35 pm
Posted by Saskwatch
Member since Feb 2016
16556 posts
Posted on 5/29/20 at 4:40 pm to
Hi, my name is George Costanza, and I too am a Marine Biologist. Poge fishers suck and that's my rebuttal
Posted by 1234567k
Baton rouge
Member since Nov 2015
2067 posts
Posted on 5/29/20 at 7:33 pm to
Gold Jerry , pure gold
Posted by Bawcephus
Member since Jul 2018
2747 posts
Posted on 5/29/20 at 11:41 pm to
quote:

BayouTiger71


I don't have a dog in the fight so to speak, but two things.

If I was confident, I'd have bet a lot more than $500.

I don't think he's bull shitting and will do as promised.
first pageprev pagePage 3 of 3Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram