Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message
locked post

Watchmen - Confused regarding Dr. Manhattan's stance on miracles

Posted on 2/21/12 at 11:38 am
Posted by GonzoLeslie
Alabama
Member since Sep 2011
3695 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 11:38 am
I'm just paraphrasing here, but he has a nice line on mars where he says, "Miracles are, by their definition, meaningless. Only things that CAN happen do happen."
I thought it was a brilliant line.

Then, a few moments later, he basically says its a miracle that each of us are born how we are.
"In each human coupling, a thousand million sperm vie for a single egg. Multiply those odds by countless generations, against the odds of your ancestors being alive, meeting, siring this precise son; that exact daughter...until your mother loves a man ...and of that union, of the thousand million children competing for fertilization, it was you, only you...(it's) like turning air to gold...thermodynamic miracle."

So, what made Dr. Manhattan change the definition of the word, "miracle"?

There are 2 basic definitions of mircale:
1. An event which breaks the laws of nature
2. An event which is divine, caused by god.

He goes from def 1, to def 3 (an improbable event), which isn't a miracle at all.

Posted by Patrick O Rly
y u do dis?
Member since Aug 2011
41187 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 12:07 pm to
I think it's just a different way of looking at the same outcome. I forget the exact number, but two people have 4 or 7 trillion genetic combination possibilities for offspring. You could make the case that the fact that you're here is a miracle, because the odds were against it.
Posted by Dr Emmett Brown
Hill Valley, CA
Member since Dec 2010
447 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 12:08 pm to
Happy Mardi Gras!!

I'm drunk b!tches!!
Posted by Green Chili Tiger
Lurking the Tin Foil Hat Board
Member since Jul 2009
47647 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 12:13 pm to
I don't think one contradicts the other. I think it's a very poetic way of saying that complexity does not make something a miracle.

You have to remember, that he was there because he was confused and frustrated.
Posted by Pectus
Internet
Member since Apr 2010
67302 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 12:19 pm to
quote:

You have to remember, that he was there because he was confused and frustrated.


Exactly. He was trying to find his place in the world. He was a God like being who was just pure energy with a conscience. He existed at all points in time. He was trying to come to grips with that especially because of what he was accused of. And in a bigger way, it was that Mars deconstruction of himself, and the Universe that lead to him being able to take the blame for the events orchestrated by Ozymandias (in the movie version at least).
Posted by GonzoLeslie
Alabama
Member since Sep 2011
3695 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 12:23 pm to
i think i may read the novel. does it go into much more detail about dr. manhattan?
Posted by Lacour
Member since Nov 2009
32949 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 12:41 pm to
Since this is a Watchmen thread let me be the first to mention the blue dong.
Posted by Patrick O Rly
y u do dis?
Member since Aug 2011
41187 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 12:48 pm to
Oh yeah. I want one. A blue dong that is. On me, not IN me. You know what I mean.
Posted by Pectus
Internet
Member since Apr 2010
67302 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 12:53 pm to
It's pretty much the same exact thing except for the means in which Ozymandias fulfills his plan, which sligthly alters the ending.
Posted by Slippery Slope
Hail Satan
Member since Nov 2010
20346 posts
Posted on 2/21/12 at 1:05 pm to
ALIEN MONSTER!!!!1!1
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram