quote:
I know plenty about football. I know Young played for Tampa for two years and threw 11 TDs to 22 Int. He then sat behind Montana for a few years.

We don’t know what Young would have done on a different team or if he would have played more years. The unknown is why I can’t put him above guys who actually did it. You’re extrapolating data to prove your opinion. The other guys actually did it.

Not to mention Young was statistically tremendous when he played in relief of Montana from 87-90, I recall he even passed for over 1K yards in 89, remarkable.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by Jcorye1

Tom Brady = GoAT

Member since Dec 2007

75122 posts

Posted on 2/2/22 at 6:03 pm to Suntiger

Eli Manning? Woof.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by ThePTExperience1969

Baton Rouge, LA

Member since Apr 2016

13360 posts

Posted on 2/2/22 at 6:03 pm to 632627

quote:
In favor of young’s inclusion on a top 10 list, I’d argue that his 1994 season is the single greatest season for a qb outside of this current generation with the video game stats.

Very good argument too, I consider Montana's 89 season, Bert Jones' 76 season, and YA Tittle's 63 season in that same class along with obviously Marino's 84 season

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by tigerfan84

Member since Dec 2003

23538 posts

Posted on 2/2/22 at 9:38 pm to ValleyofDeath

Brady
Peyton Manning
Montana
Marino
Elway
Brees
Rodgers
Favre
Unitas
Steve Young

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by gumbo2176

Member since May 2018

18150 posts

Posted on 2/2/22 at 9:44 pm to ValleyofDeath

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Bart Starr
Terry Bradshaw
Joe Montana
Dan Marino
John Elway
Brett Favre
Johnny Unitas
Aaron Rodgers

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by SPEEDY

2005 Tiger Smack Poster of the Year

Member since Dec 2003

85440 posts

Posted on 2/2/22 at 9:45 pm to ValleyofDeath

quote:
10. T. Bradshaw

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by ThanosIsADemocrat

The Garden

Member since May 2018

9395 posts

Posted on 2/2/22 at 11:24 pm to StrongOffer

quote:
Anybody that has Rodgers or Favre over Brees just doesn't like him for personal reasons. There is no argument for either over Brees.

Wut

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by TigahJay

New Orleans

Member since Sep 2015

10856 posts

Posted on 2/2/22 at 11:28 pm to ValleyofDeath

Lol at all of these people overrating Favre. If you have him above Brees on your list, you’re a moron.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by GeauxHouston

Midland, Texas

Member since Nov 2013

4853 posts

Posted on 2/3/22 at 6:31 am to ValleyofDeath

1. Brady
2. Manning
T3. Brees
T3. Rodgers
5. Montana
6. Marino
7. Elway
8. Favre
9. Steve Young
10. Mahomes

Honorable Mentions:
Big Ben, Rivers, Eli, Fouts, Kelly

Aren’t on list bc so long ago:
Staubach, Graham, Starr, Unitas.

I know some will go insane that Mahomes is in the top 10 but talent wise he is for sure. Not to mention he is an MVP, SB MVP, 4x Pro Bowler and has thrown for 19K yards and 151 TDs in 4 years of starting.
Also there is no point in adding people from the 60s as there is just no shot they are better than anyone on the list.

This post was edited on 2/3/22 at 6:32 am

Page 1 2 3 4