re: Stop comparing this to 2004 Troy. 2 big differences

quote:

---

people act like LSU lost more than it did. i believe we lose more next year

---

I think without a doubt we will be WAY better next year.

one thing with miles that i do like is i dont have to worry bout the oline.

quote:

---

I think without a doubt we will be WAY better next year.

---

we lose a lot from this team without even counting juniors

quote:

---

one thing with miles that i do like is i dont have to worry bout the oline.

---

if we lose ciron black, we will all worry

f jarvis jones

quote:

---

quote:
1. 2004 LSU, as a program, was not established like 2008 LSU is. Saban was still building a program and it didn't have the depth to deal with losing 3 key juniors and a bunch of seniors. 2008 does have that depth

2. 2008 Troy DOMINATED LSU FOR 75% OF THE GAME. 2004 Troy kept it close in a sloppy game where we turned it over. at no point did 2008 get dominated by 2004 Troy.




considering your orginal argument.

quote:
so you'd take 2004 LSU over 2008 LSU in a talent competition?



which would you take?

---

i don't want you to miss this without giving an answer.

your so sure the 08 team was more talented yet its the team that got dominated...why would you so easily choose that squad over 04. Troy sucks this year and they dont' have demarcus ware like '04.

quote:

---

why would you so easily choose that squad over 04.

---

the only position 2004 had a talent advantage was CB

2004 vs 2008 starters

QB
Marcus Randall
Jarrett Lee

RB
Joseph Addai
Charles Scott

FB
Kevin Steltz
Quinn Johnson

WR
Dwayne Bowe
Brandon Lafell

WR
Craig Davis
D Byrd

TE
David Jones
Richard Dickson

OT
Andrew Whitworth
Ciron Black

OG
Rudy Niswanger
Herman Johnson

C
Ben Wilkerson
Brett Helms

OG
Terrell Mcgill
Lyle Hitt

OT
Dyakowski ?
Barksdale


DE
Marcus Spears
Tyson Jackson

DT
Cladue Wroten
RJF

DT
Kyle Williams
Charles Alexander

DE
? Sean Merrill
Kirston Pittman

LB
Cameron Vaughn
Perry Riley

LB
Lionel Turner
Darry Beckwith

LB
?EJ Kuale
Kelvin Sheppard

CB
Corey Webster
Chris Hawkins

CB
Travis Daniels
Jai Eugene

SS
?Jesse Daniels
Harry Coleman

FS
Laron Landry
Curtis Taylor


Did the best I could as far as the 2004 starters. Anyway, those saying the talent this year is so far superior to the 2004 team should compare them first.

quote:

---

the coaching was not great, def could use improvment. That what you want to hear??

---

no

i want dumbass tepper tigers like bayourant to stop comparing the 2 games. other than our opponent having the same name, the games were completely different. 2004 Troy is like 2008 AU or 2008 MSU, not 2008 Troy

quote:

---

the only position 2004 had a talent advantage was CB

---

Laron Landry and Jessie Daniels sucked

quote:

---

We had Bowe, Davis, and Doucet. Much more talented than these guys we have.

---

RS Jr LAfell, Sr, Byrd, Jr dickson, and So tolliver > So Bowe/Davis and Fs Doucet

it ain't close

quote:

---

and Scott was a no show against them this year.

---

not his fault we make it obvious when we run and make it easy to stop him

and let's not forget keiland and murphy, who were not used last night for some reason

quote:

---

the only position 2004 had a talent advantage was CB

---

way to find the one thing in my statement you actually want to answer and miss the actual question.

you just said 08 was more talented all around and you seem to pick them in a talent competition, but your original arguement is talking about an 04 team that played a much more talented troy team and a 08 team that just got dominated for 75 % of the game.

am i reading your responses wrong?

quote:

---

RS Jr LAfell, Sr, Byrd, Jr dickson, and So tolliver > So Bowe/Davis and Fs Doucet

---

omg do ya really believe that. bowe/davis/doucet is the best wr tandem in lsu history.