re: All Time LSU team

Posted by Lsupimp

Ersatz Amerika-97.6% phony & fake

Member since Nov 2003

84097 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:27 am to Toadfrggy82

I think your list is great, btw. I’d add another one- one of my personal favorites, who has the undeniable scorecard to back up my list. I’d put him ahead of Anderson/ Beckwith:

Al Richardson, an All-American in 1982 as a senior, is still the Tigers' all-time leader in tackles with 452.

Regarded as one of the best linebackers to ever play for the Tigers, Richardson also holds the single game tackle record with his dominant performance against South Carolina in 1982 when he accounted for 21 tackles. He was an All American that year.

And then there is Chris Williams at defensive back who had 20 ints ( the record ) including 8 in one season. Lol. But I like your db list. Just too many guys that were great to include them all.

Posted by lsupicker

Member since Oct 2015

1357 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:30 am to Toadfrggy82

Gonna get clobbered, but I don't think Stingley belongs as an all time great. One season yes.

Posted by Toadfrggy82

Kaplan, La

Member since Aug 2023

1418 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:30 am to Lsupimp

quote:
Al Richardson, an All-American in 1982 as a senior, is still the Tigers' all-time leader in tackles with 452. Regarded as one of the best linebackers to ever play for the Tigers, Richardson also holds the single game tackle record with his dominant performance against South Carolina in 1982 when he accounted for 21 tackles. He was an All American that year. And then there is Chris Williams at defensive back who had 20 ints ( the record ) including 8 in one season. Lol. But I like your db list. Just too many guys that were great to include them all.

That’s what I needed, going to add them

Posted by ATLTiger

#TreyBiletnikoffs

Member since Sep 2003

45416 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:37 am to Toadfrggy82

quote:
OT-Andrew Whitworth/Campbell/Barksdale
OT-Kevin Mawee/La’el Collins/Eric Andolsec

I like Barksdale and La'el, and I think a lot of Campbell. But you gotta have Ciron in here. 4 year starter at LT, AA/ All SEC accolades.

Posted by Toadfrggy82

Kaplan, La

Member since Aug 2023

1418 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:39 am to ATLTiger

quote:
I like Barksdale and La'el, and I think a lot of Campbell. But you gotta have Ciron in here. 4 year starter at LT, AA/ All SEC accolades.

Going to put him in for Barksdale

Posted by JonTheTigerFan

Central, LA

Member since Nov 2003

6936 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:39 am to Toadfrggy82

quote:
Because I picture him in 90 degree weather on the sideline in Oakland leaned out with a beanie on lol

What’s that got to do with his time at LSU?

Posted by Toadfrggy82

Kaplan, La

Member since Aug 2023

1418 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:41 am to JonTheTigerFan

quote:
What’s that got to do with his time at LSU?

Nothing at all, but he ain’t going in top 3, he never won nothing I put him in,I need to quit all that, he is top 3 until big Nuss takes his spot. I hope Daniels does good, but he just don’t fire me up like Nuss, you know he ain’t scared to sling it, he reminds me of a young Burrow in ways, people can hate on me for saying I just don’t think Jayden will
Throw it downfield. A 5th year senior that has played 4 full seasons usually doesn’t change much

This post was edited on 8/25/23 at 9:46 am

Posted by beautigers65

Member since Oct 2015

62 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:43 am to Toadfrggy82

I did a different exercise. Here is a list of "modern players" from LSU that would be on my All LSU NFL Team (based on NFL careers):

QB Joe Burrow
RB Kevin Faulk
RB Leonard Fournette
WR Jarvis Landry
WR Justin Jefferson
WR Ja'Marr Chase
TE Robert Royal
OT Andrew Whitworth
OT La'el Collins
OC Kevin Mawae
OG Alan Faneca
OG Trai Turner
DT Henry Thomas
DT Kyle Williams
DE Leonard Marshall
DE Danielle Hunter
LB Michael Brooks
LB Bradie James
LB Eric Hill
S Tyrann Mathieu
S Jamal Adams
CB Patrick Peterson
CB Tre'Davious White
RET Eddie Kennison
K Wade Richey
P Donnie Jones
LS Brian Kinchen

Honorable Mentions:
QB Bert Jones
C Todd McClure
G-T Dan Alexander
WR Eric Martin
G-T Lance Smith
DB Eugene Daniel
DB Ryan Clark
DT Michael Brockers
WR Odell Beckham Jr.
LB Bradie James
DB Greg Jackson
WR Carlos Carson
RB Joseph Addai
WR Dwayne Bowe
LB-DE A.J. Duhe
RB Dalton Hilliard
DT Anthony McFarland
WR Brandon LaFell
OLB Deion Jones
DB Tory James
LB Devin White
OLB Kwon Alexander
DB LaRon Landry
FS Eric Reid
DB Mike Williams
DB Mark Roman
DT Glenn Dorsey
DE Marcus Spears
WR Devery Henderson
RB Harvey Williams
DE Tyson Jackson

This is a list of older players who did well in the NFL:
S Johnny Robinson
HB Steve Van Buren
QB Y.A. Tittle
TE-RB Billy Cannon
FB Jim Taylor
DE Mel Branch
DB Tommy Casanova
E Gaynell Tinsley
DT Fred Miller
DB-P Jerry Stovall
K-P Tommy Davis
DE Paul Miller
E Ken Kavanaugh
DB-HB Jim Cason
DT-T Ray Collins
LB Roy Winston
DE-LB-C George Tarasovic
G-T-C John Demarie
LB Dennis Gaubatz
DT-DE Earl Leggett
FB Earl Gros
DB Ken Konz
TE Billy Truax
TE-SE Billy Masters

This post was edited on 8/25/23 at 10:06 am

Posted by Toadfrggy82

Kaplan, La

Member since Aug 2023

1418 posts

Posted on 8/25/23 at 9:47 am to beautigers65

You left off big Dorsey and Spears and no way I can put Landry over OBJ, Josh Reed, Clayton

This post was edited on 8/25/23 at 9:49 am

2 ...