Here are the full teams pre trade (minus D/ST and Kickers) for reference:

Team A:
J. Hurts
J. Taylor
S. Barkley
J. Waddle
A. Robinson
T. Kelce
D. Henderson
Bench:
J. Jeudy
AJ Dillon
C. Edmonds
D. Harris
R. Penny
Treylon Burks

Team B:
J. Allen
A. Kamara
J. Robinson
S. Diggs
M. Thomas
D. Waller
M. Evans
Bench:
B. Aiyuk
D. Pierce
A. Lazard
K. Walker
M. Gesicki
D. Hillard
E. Mitchell (IR)

I feel pretty solid on my thoughts on this trade but I wanted to hear some other people's thoughts because I suck at evaluating trades/potential trades in Fantasy

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by DeathValley85

Member since May 2011

17184 posts

Posted on 9/22/22 at 11:14 am to Hazelnut

Evans side

Evans side gets a starter, other side does not.

2 ...

Report Post

Posted by BhamTigah

Lurker since Jan 2003

Member since Jan 2007

14114 posts

Posted on 9/22/22 at 11:15 am to DeathValley85

What DV85 said.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by Hazelnut

Member since May 2011

16433 posts

Posted on 9/22/22 at 11:19 am to DeathValley85

Okay thank you cause that's exactly how I feel. I would be giving up Evans and I just don't see how it's a good trade. He originally asked what it would take to get Evans and I threw out Barkley and he scoffed at that. I would've been willing to give up Evans + another piece for Barkley but I just don't see how getting any of his RBs lower than Barkley would be worth trading Evans.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by DeathValley85

Member since May 2011

17184 posts

Posted on 9/22/22 at 11:23 am to Hazelnut

quote:
I would've been willing to give up Evans + another piece for Barkley but I just don't see how getting any of his RBs lower than Barkley would be worth trading Evans.

Only Barkley/Taylor make your team better. Otherwise makes no sense to trade away Evans.

ETA: it’s like he thought he could just stack up a bunch of RB2/3s and get Evans