re: Joiner or Williams?

quote:

---

Williams. I don’t like Joiners tape.

---

Patrick Queen & Devin White had better RB film IMO.

I know what you mean, Joiner just looks slow, doesn't have much agility, sort of a souped-up fullback or H-back. IDK if he looks slow because of his height or if the defenders are that fast. Eric Dickerson use to look slow on film too, but he was moving. It's a tough choice. But, wouldn't it be nice to go into Alabama and get a top player from Saban instead of the other way around (like it's been for a few years now). One thing stands out to me, Joiner really wants to be a Tiger, from what I've read. Williams, IDK. Personally, I'd rather have a player that wants to be with me than one I have to nearly force to be with me. Plus, there's some fast and quick players in this class the mold of Williams, not many big bone-crushers like Joiner. Joiner would make a really good H-back, good blocker and can run and catch. Probably would be more valuable all-around than Williams. I'd take Joiner.