Not really. Brady’s accolades, stats and overall resume are clearly the best in history, and consensus is that he is the goat based on that. However, there are many people that acknowledge that in terms of peak playing ability, Rodgers is the best. Aaron Rodgers is the perfect qb, he has no flaws. Rodgers just wasn’t fortunate enough to play with bellichek, Moss, gronk or a top ranked defense during his career. It’s similar to the jerry rice/randy moss argument. Rice is the goat receiver, but at his best, Moss was more dangerous.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by MidnightVibe

Member since Feb 2015

7896 posts

Posted on 10/13/17 at 8:42 am to 632627

quote:
Not really. Brady’s accolades, stats and overall resume are clearly the best in history, and consensus is that he is the goat based on that. However, there are many people that acknowledge that in terms of peak playing ability, Rodgers is the best. Aaron Rodgers is the perfect qb, he has no flaws. Rodgers just wasn’t fortunate enough to play with bellichek, Moss, gronk or a top ranked defense during his career. It’s similar to the jerry rice/randy moss argument. Rice is the goat receiver, but at his best, Moss was more dangerous.

Well thenI disagree as to what criteria--i.e. what questions are we answering--should be considered in determining the GOAT. Because, if the following is true....

quote:
However, there are many people that acknowledge that in terms of peak playing ability, Rodgers is the best. Aaron Rodgers is the perfect qb, he has no flaws

And Aaron Rodgers isn't the GOAT, then the GOAT argument is nebulous and stupid.

3 ...

Report Post

More Sports - Replies to Post

Return To Board

Page 1

Return To Board