Started By
Message

re: Tesla Semi could be ‘the biggest catalyst in trucking in decades’

Posted on 9/8/17 at 10:11 am to
Posted by Darth_Vader
A galaxy far, far away
Member since Dec 2011
64948 posts
Posted on 9/8/17 at 10:11 am to
quote:

Not sure why you're getting defensive. He made a solid point, you keep asking him to explain and give details, but you really haven' done the same, like he has.


I have explained and given details. My main point is the extra weight of an electric truck versus a standard. Look at it this way, a Chevy Malibu weight 3,100 lbs. It's about the same size as a Tesla Model S. But the Tesla weighs over 4,600 lbs. That difference is huge, especially when you start talking about big trucks versus cars. The bottom line is an electric truck will weigh more than a standard truck. Period, they just will. And even if they can pull twice the weight of a standard truck it won't matter because they will still be restricted by the roads themselves and the legal limit states will allow to travel on those roads. Again, the heavier the truck, the less weight it can legally haul. And the less freight it can haul, the less economically feesable the truck.
Posted by shel311
McKinney, Texas
Member since Aug 2004
111207 posts
Posted on 9/8/17 at 10:28 am to
quote:

My main point is the extra weight of an electric truck versus a standard. Look at it this way, a Chevy Malibu weight 3,100 lbs. It's about the same size as a Tesla Model S. But the Tesla weighs over 4,600 lbs. That difference is huge, especially when you start talking about big trucks versus cars. The bottom line is an electric truck will weigh more than a standard truck. Period, they just will.



LINK

quote:

The key, Potter said, is that much of the trucking industry overestimates weight needs. That leaves room on trucks for the weight of the large battery packs that provide power for electric vehicles.

About “85 percent of the Class 8 trucks on the road in the U.S. operate below the 80,000-pound legal limit, and are therefore relatively insensitive to weight,” Potter said. “Range is a potentially more challenging problem.”


quote:

“We think many trucks could make the transition to an electric drivetrain without adding more than 4,000 pounds in gross weight,” Potter said.



quote:

And he called the estimate conservative because it assumes manufacturers and carriers are not making any efforts to shave weight from their vehicles. Potter believes the trucking industry can “easily” find weight savings of 2,000 pounds in a semi-tractor and trailer package.

“We have concluded that making the transition to EVs will NOT be too heavy for most fleets to stomach,” Potter wrote in his report.

In fact, most fleets don't care how much their trucks weigh, Potter said.

“There is a misperception that fleets obsess over vehicle weight,” he said. “Some fleets will rightly disagree with this statement, but in fact, only a small portion (2 percent to 7 percent) of trucks frequently operate near the 80,000-pound maximum allowable combined weight limit,”

Most of those are bulk haulers that have revenue tied to the mass of the commodity they are delivering.

“But such fleets are rare,” Potter said. “Most fleets run out of space in their trailers long before they approach the 80,000-pound pound threshold.”

He estimates that 80 percent of Class 8 trucks haul less than 70,000 pounds. That leaves lots of room to absorb the weight of electric vehicle components.

“If these fleets cared so deeply about minimizing vehicle weight and maximizing payload, then they would be mimicking bulk haulers by investing in lightweight trucks,” Potter said. “But they aren't.”
Posted by Korkstand
Member since Nov 2003
28732 posts
Posted on 9/8/17 at 10:37 am to
quote:

My main point is the extra weight of an electric truck versus a standard.
I'm trying to tell you that's a pretty weak point.
quote:

Look at it this way, a Chevy Malibu weight 3,100 lbs. It's about the same size as a Tesla Model S. But the Tesla weighs over 4,600 lbs.
Why would you pick a very underpowered vehicle with a tiny engine to compare to the Tesla? Why not pick something more comparable like some Mercedes model or something? The Tesla would still rip the doors off of it, but at least it would come close to packing the same power. I know why, because they're about the same weight and it doesn't fit your narrative.
quote:

That difference is huge, especially when you start talking about big trucks versus cars.
Actually, the difference could very likely be smaller when you're talking about big trucks, because a higher fraction of the weight of the vehicle is "truck" rather than battery.
quote:

Again, the heavier the truck, the less weight it can legally haul. And the less freight it can haul, the less economically feesable the truck.
Again, you're not accounting for the fact that the cost of the fuel and driver are HUGE factors in the economic feasibility of a truck. With those costs eliminated, the loads can be lighter and still be more profitable.

Though I still think you'll be surprised by the weight of these trucks.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram