re: Virgin Islands for HoneyMoon..Island with the best food is?

If you are in Virgin Gorda, try to run up to Anegada for the day at least once. Totally different island structure. I dont want to get in the weeds about geology (because I will misspeak), but basically most islands are a result of volcanic or tectonic plate collision. Anegada is made up entirely from coral so it is flat.

The charter companies used to prohibit their boats from going there, since the approach is very technical in shallow water. However, I recall there is a charter and at the dock is a beach side bar/restaurant that grills Caribbean lobster.