re: Video diary of TGBFTL @ MSU

Now I know, you have no clue what your talking about so please. Show me any video of LSU sounding better than this. We are one

quote:

---

Now I know, you have no clue what your talking about so please. Show me any video of LSU sounding better than this

---

We get it. You think SU is the best band in the world. To prove your point you post a link to a video of them blowing their 697 horns as loud as they can. Some parts are almost inaudible.

I don't think. They have actual rankings every year NCAA and USA today .....SI....look it up

I have to disagree, I'm still waiting on that video. Doesn't have to be LSU. Any of those bands I would love to see it. It's something in the marching band community that we talk about all the time. I think because you don't know enough about southern ( or any non-PWC) you believe that. But yeah I agree it is apples to oranges. Just not in the way that you think

quote:

---

I have to disagree, I'm still waiting on that video. Doesn't have to be LSU. Any of those bands I would love to see it. It's something in the marching band community that we talk about all the time. I think because you don't know enough about southern ( or any non-PWC) you believe that. But yeah I agree it is apples to oranges. Just not in the way that you think

---

This thread is about highlighting the LSU band's experience in Starkville over the weekend.

It has nothing remotely to do with SU, so I'm still not sure why the hell you're even here.

quote:

---

Now I know, you have no clue what your talking about so please. Show me any video of LSU sounding better than this.

---

Dude, you really don't know what YOU'RE talking about. (and use some proper grammar by the way)

From a former member of TGBFTL, an LSU School of Music Grad, and a lifelong musician, I know good music and that blowing as hard as you can into a horn, so loud that it's out of tune (badly) is NOT good music.

Here's some great musicianship from TGBFTL and it's not even their best. It's controlled, beautiful, shows real dynamics (do you know what that means?) and it completely blows your video of SU away!

Let Us Break Bread

In any case, just know what you're (not your) talking about before you talk crap about the band. I'm not trying to dis SU's band. I can appreciate the hard work that ANY college band puts in. But I also know quality when I hear it and LSU ranks up there among the best.

and

Thank you. I'm a former TGBFTL member as well and always thought Southern's "musicianship" was a joke.

Yes, they can scream, and yes they are flashy, but the sheer amount of out of tune instruments is cringe-worthy.

quote:

---

In show style bands. Songs like break bread are used as warm up songs. Jackson State actually plays it. So because of the style of playing is different doesn't make it bad. Because you guys don't scream doesn't mean it's bad. Having power is one thing but having control is another. But since we are on the topic of control and dynamics.......here you go

---

We fricking get it already. Is there an SU board you can post this shite on? This is a damn thread about LSU's band trip to State. Your link still sounds like shite. Heavy horns and no depth what so ever. LSU has more depth in a simple song like Hey Baby. SU is what you said, a show style band. LSU is not. Muscially LSU if vastly superior. In terms of entertainment and dancing it's SU. Congrats.