LSU

DE - Jermauria Rasco (SR) 4 star, number 90
DT - Christian LaCouture (SO) 4 star, number 277
DT - Davon Godchaux (FR) 4 star, number 148
DE - Danielle Hunter (JR) 4 star, number 194
SLB - Louis Lamar (JR) 4 star, number 282
MLB - Kendell Beckwith (SO) 4 star, number 74
WLB - Kwon Alexander (JR) 4 star, number 86
CB - Jalen Collins (JR) 3 star, number 387
S - Jalen Milss (JR) 3 star, number 787
S - Ronald Martin (SR) 3 star, number 653
CB - Tre'Davious White (SO) 4 star, number 55

bama

DE - Jonathon Allen (SO) 5 star, number 16
NT - A'Shawn Robinson (SO) 5 star, number 33
DE - Jarran Reed (JR) 4 star, number 13 (juco)
SLB - Denzel Devall (JR) 4 star, number 139
MLB - Trey DePriest (SR) 5 star, number 29
WLB - Reggie Ragland (SO) 4 star, number 41
JAK - Xzavier Dickson (SR) 4 star, number 34
CB - Geno Smith (JR) 4 star, number 61
SS - Landon Collins (JR) 5 star, number 7
FS - Nick Perry (SR) 4 star, number 245
CB - Cyrus Jones (JR) 4 star, number 43

TCU

DLE - Josh Caraway (SO) 2 star, number 2714
DT - Chuck Hunter (SR) 3 star, number 406
DT - Davion Pierson (JR) 3 star, number 898
RDE - Mike Tuana (JR) 2 star, number 3055
MLB - Marcus Mallet (SR) 3 star, number 696
SLB - Paul Dawson (SR) unranked
CB - Ranthony Texada (RS FR) 3 star, number 787
SS - Sam Carter (SR) 3 star, number 359
FS - Derrick Kindred (JR) 2 star, number 2721
WS - Chris Hackett (JR) 3 star, number 680
CB - Kevin White (SR) 3 star, number 1283

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by MastrShake

SoCal

Member since Nov 2008

7281 posts

Posted on 1/6/15 at 1:32 pm to MastrShake

trying to compare rosters got a little convoluted. giving a 3 to every 3 star for example seemed dumb because, as you can see with TCU, number 359 and number 1283 are both 3 stars, and that's a hell of a gap.

so to give more weight to higher prospects, I gave a 7 to every prospect ranked 1-50, a 6 to every prospect from 51-100, and so on like this

1 - 50 = 7
51 – 100 = 6
101 – 200 = 5
201 – 300 = 4
301 – 500 = 3
501 – 1000 = 2
1001 and up = 1

I subtracted a 2 from each player if they came from a juco or prep school (because they were being ranked in a much smaller pool), then added it up and divided by 11 for an average

ALA - 6.18
LSU - 4.45
CLE - 3.63
PSU - 2.81
TCU - 1.72

for the class I simply gave a 1 to every FR, a 2 to every SO, and so on, adding a 1 if they were a RS. Clemson had the most upperclassman of the 5 teams, while LSU was the youngest

CLE - 9.50
TCU - 9.00
PSU - 8.50
ALA - 8.25
LSU - 7.50

then I added the sets together to see who had the best combination of talent and experience to get the rankings from the top post.

look, just fricking hire Shoop and O as the DL coach, ok. Im not sure how much more clear I can make this.

This post was edited on 1/6/15 at 1:34 pm

6 ...

Report Post

Tiger Rant - Replies to Post

Return To Board

Page 1

Return To Board