re: Siap, McShay and Hoge discuss Mettenberger...

quote:

---

Yeah I'm sure y'all know so much more than these guys.. what idiots.

---

You do know all these draft player rankings and mocks are just speculation? All of the "expert draft analysis" have completely different lists. Some have Mett as a top 5 QB. Some have him a top 3 QB. Some have him between 7-10. Its all speculation.

Nobody is a "draft expert". If someone was, they wouldnt have nearly as many screw ups on their lists as they do, and most likely would be a GM of a team.

Mel Kiper compared JaMarcus to John Elway. He also said Ricky Stanzi would end up being the best QB in the 2011 draft, and that Mike Williams (USC) would be a Hall of Famer WR and was the best player in the 2005 draft. McShay said Blaine Gabbert would be a better pro player than Cam Newton and should be the #1 QB taken. He also had Mark Sanchez ahead of Stafford.

Point is, nobody knows who will do what at the next level. Its easy to predict that a guy like Andrew Luck is going to go #1 overall and be great at the next level. And that Clowney is an elite prospect. Those are givens. But when there isnt a clear cut top QB prospect, its tough. These "experts" opinion on Mett vary from a late 1st round to a 4th round pick. Thats not really telling me anything that I dont already know.

Its all a crapshoot. Am I saying I know more than these guys do? Nope. But they dont know that much more than some people that pay attention to this kinda stuff. Its pretty much a 50/50 guess.