re: Joaquin Phoenix vs Leonardo DiCaprio - who's the more talented actor?

You know it's funny you seem to be the only one saying that.

Phoenix not only won the golden globe and got nominated for an Oscar for Walk the Line, but Johnny and June Cash themselves were pleased with it before they died.

As a matter of fact there have been several stories and interviews over the years from Johnny Cash's friends, family, and music critics who all have praised the job that Phoenix did. You seem to personally not like it and you're without a shadow of a doubt in a very small minority that would think that.