re: Is this good for us.

quote:

---

But you can't tell me that if Barkley was quarterback for any other team and wouldn't have gotten this much hype in college he would even be considered a 1st round pick.

---

While I agree with that statement, that's not the topic.

The topic is your idiotic statement which was essentially, "Barkley went to USC, like Leinert. Because they are both highly regarded QBs from USC, and because Leinart sucks, it's safe to assume that Barkley will suck."

That's lazy and flawed thinking.

Barkley may in fact end up sucking, but his going to USC has nothing to do with it.