re: Official Season 12 American Idol Discussion Thread

quote:

---

if she stops with them damn accents she is a great judge. i was able to see through the voices and notice she was a good judge early on though. (unlike some people )

---

Her natural voice is awful, but the "I want to have your baby" crap with every damn contestant she liked, boy, girl or half boy/half girl was just stupid. She lost credibility with that stupid stuff and the accents, too. That's the problem. If she'd started out the way she is now, she wouldn't have gotten all the hell. It was all about her is what it was up until she got called on the carpet. Then, she had a stupid twitter war with a high school contestant when he was kicked off. Give me a break.

ETA: If loving her is right, then I don't want to be wrong.