re: Crackpot ASOIAF Theories SPOILERS

quote:

---

Hooded Man=Theon reflection of himself
Hooded Man=Benjen
Hooded Man=Blackfish
Hooded Man=Harwin
Hooded Man=Jon
Hooded Man=Mance

---

Can someone explain why "Hooded Man=Jaime" isn't a theory?

Here's my thinking: Brienne tells Lady Stoneheart that she'll kill Jaime. She goes and finds him and instead of killing him she gives him a chance to fulfill his vow to return the Stark girls. They hear that Arya is at Winterfell and go up there to get her. They sneak in and start killing people ninja-style and then Jaime meets Reek for the hooded man scene. Jaime would recognize him as Ned Stark's ward because they met when Robert went to Winterfell in the first book.

I know there's some reason this can't be it but I can't put my finger on it.


Edited because I suck at words.