re: Crackpot ASOIAF Theories SPOILERS

quote:

---

and had hundreds of thousands of men/banner men fight the True King based on that?

---

Yep, there have been similar wars fought before.

quote:

---

she didn't love her husband and child enough to stop all of winterfell from joining forces?

---

It would mean the death of her kid, and Rhaegar was already married, so it was a pretty big problem. Plus Jon was prophesied to be The Prince that was Promised, so he would have to defend him.

quote:

---

If that's where the writer wants to go, fine, but it's not believable.

---

Read the novels, because you're coming off as just plain dumb. Ned didn't know about the kid until Lyanna was in labor and the war was already over. He had to lie to protect Jon, because Robert would have without question killed Jon. It's rude to delve into a Bastard's origin, so it protected Jon. There were some people during the war that had some close flings with Ned, to where there are suspects on whose mother Jon Snow would be.