- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Handgun for Home Defense
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:28 pm
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:28 pm
I know this topic has been done a lot before, but I'll be going to the gun range over the next few months to try out different guns.
These are a list of hand guns you can rent.
LINK
Which ones should I try out?
For a gun, I'm looking for something with good stopping power. I don't want the guy to be standing or have a chance to shoot back at me.
Been hearing about a lot of break-ins in and around the neighborhood. If it were just me, I probably wouldn't worry about it. I don't have much to take. But the thought of someone breaking into my house and harming my gf has me
Not looking for a shot gun.
These are a list of hand guns you can rent.
LINK
Which ones should I try out?
For a gun, I'm looking for something with good stopping power. I don't want the guy to be standing or have a chance to shoot back at me.
Been hearing about a lot of break-ins in and around the neighborhood. If it were just me, I probably wouldn't worry about it. I don't have much to take. But the thought of someone breaking into my house and harming my gf has me
Not looking for a shot gun.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:33 pm to CrocsWithSocks
Only been here for a few months but for sure this sounds like the gun to get from everyone on this board.....
quote:
JUDGE
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:33 pm to CrocsWithSocks
:beatdeadhorse:
Yeah this topic has been discussed ad nauseam. There are a lot of guns on that list. Do a search and find one of the recommended ones that fits into your budget.
Yeah this topic has been discussed ad nauseam. There are a lot of guns on that list. Do a search and find one of the recommended ones that fits into your budget.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:34 pm to CrocsWithSocks
quote:
TAURUS JUDGE 45/410
Can believe they rent such a powerful weapon.
Try the same caliber in different brands that will give you a good feel of how they handle.
Good selection there.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:35 pm to CrocsWithSocks
No way that I would have enough time to shoot all the guns I would choose from that list.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:37 pm to INFIDEL
Exactly... there are a lot I want to try; I was just hoping that people on here could narrow it down to 4 or 5.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:45 pm to CrocsWithSocks
Beretta Px4-40
Colt 1911 Government (you will LOVE the 1911)
Pick a Glock in 40 or 45
Ruger SR9
Sig 229 in 40 (I'm not a sig guy, but I hear good things)
Springfield xdm in 40 or 45 (My favorite "plastic" gun. I choose the xd over Glock all day, but it's personal preference)
S&W m&p 40 or 45
Springfield rangeofficer
S&W 686 (For what you are needing I would give a lot of thought to a revolver. I lOVE a wheel gun)
Colt 1911 Government (you will LOVE the 1911)
Pick a Glock in 40 or 45
Ruger SR9
Sig 229 in 40 (I'm not a sig guy, but I hear good things)
Springfield xdm in 40 or 45 (My favorite "plastic" gun. I choose the xd over Glock all day, but it's personal preference)
S&W m&p 40 or 45
Springfield rangeofficer
S&W 686 (For what you are needing I would give a lot of thought to a revolver. I lOVE a wheel gun)
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:49 pm to CrocsWithSocks
I would look at the springfield xd line and the glock line. If it will be used strictly for home defense I would get a full size pistol in 45 caliber. I would get one with a rail to attach a light and or lazer. Increase your chances of being successful if you ever have to use it. These are simple to operate types of weapons that go bang when you pull the trigger. Top gun is a nice indoor range as well if you have never been there
Posted on 2/11/12 at 2:50 pm to TexasTiger
TT just gave you some good info. Simple is good for home defense.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 3:11 pm to CrocsWithSocks
Pick any fullsize 9 off that list. I say while were having this conversation we might as well bring in the 9mm v .40 v .45 argument. I recommend the 9mm because the likely hood of an event ever happening is slim to nil. The "knock down power" you speak of will be irrelevant if all shots are placed properly at that range. Lastly, because 9mm ammo is half the price of .45 you will be more likely to go practice shooting. Your proficiency with the gun in the scenario you describe is fully dependent on your practice. Relying on "knock down power" to supplement your lack of skill with the tool is foolish.
You should be more open minded to a shotgun for HD because that is it's bread and butta. Unless you just want to get a handgun for the sake of getting a handgun and HD is the only reason your GF will allow it to happen because she wears the pants.
Having said that, I have nothing against .40 and .45. I recommend 9mm because he is a noob.
You should be more open minded to a shotgun for HD because that is it's bread and butta. Unless you just want to get a handgun for the sake of getting a handgun and HD is the only reason your GF will allow it to happen because she wears the pants.
Having said that, I have nothing against .40 and .45. I recommend 9mm because he is a noob.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:11 pm to Propagandalf
Propagandalf makes a great argument for the 9mm. I just bought a Glock gen4 9mm and I love it.
I was tossing around the idea of getting a .40 for "stopping power" as well. I bought mine at Hebert Guns during the Glock sale and they had a few reps there from Glock. The guy convinced me to get the 9mm because of the cheaper ammo, more bullets in the clip and he said with the advancements they've made in ballistics recently a hollow-point 9mm round has great stopping power.
Not sure if you are single or not but the thing that pushed me over the edge was the guy reccomended that I get a gun my wife would feel comfortable shooting in the event I wasn't home.
I choose the 9mm over the .40 because there is less recoil.
I was tossing around the idea of getting a .40 for "stopping power" as well. I bought mine at Hebert Guns during the Glock sale and they had a few reps there from Glock. The guy convinced me to get the 9mm because of the cheaper ammo, more bullets in the clip and he said with the advancements they've made in ballistics recently a hollow-point 9mm round has great stopping power.
Not sure if you are single or not but the thing that pushed me over the edge was the guy reccomended that I get a gun my wife would feel comfortable shooting in the event I wasn't home.
I choose the 9mm over the .40 because there is less recoil.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:14 pm to INFIDEL
quote:
Pick a Glock in 40 or 45
I would change that to 9mm or 45. If choosing between 9 and 40 I go with 9 all day. Less recoil, more capacity, cheaper. 45 is has a balistic superiority that if you can handle it, it is worth it.
Sig 229 in 40 (I'm not a sig guy, but I hear good things)
My first duty gun. If you hate the Glock/XD trigger pull give this a whirl. A barrell change in a 229 and you have .357 auto. Great round, but expensive.
quote:
Colt 1911 Government (you will LOVE the 1911)
Agree.
quote:
S&W 686 (For what you are needing I would give a lot of thought to a revolver. I lOVE a wheel gun)
Agree big time.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:16 pm to CrocsWithSocks
You say no shotgun but if you want a true home defense weapon that is the way to go...think of this...if you are asleep when someone comes in, what gun will you do better with...a pistol that you can't see the sights yet or a shotgun that if the pump doesn't get their attention, the wide pattern it provides will. Also think of her, unless she spends time with a handgun, the shotgun is best for her as well.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:21 pm to Five0
quote:
I would change that to 9mm or 45. If choosing between 9 and 40 I go with 9 all day. Less recoil, more capacity, cheaper. 45 is has a balistic superiority that if you can handle it, it is worth it.
That's a good point and I didn't expect the 5-0 to make it. Most law enforcement guys I know are in love with the 40, but it really doesn't fill any gap. FBI love child that has risen to fame without really doing anything better then other rounds. I suggested it because I have an unwarranted dislike of the 9mm!
I would go 45 all day long. That is, unless you can find a 46.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:23 pm to CrocsWithSocks
quote:
Handgun for Home Defense
Since you are asking this question, I'd get a wheel gun first and maybe graduate into an auto.
The laser is a good thought.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:24 pm to Propagandalf
quote:
Pick any fullsize 9 off that list. I say while were having this conversation we might as well bring in the 9mm v .40 v .45 argument. I recommend the 9mm because the likely hood of an event ever happening is slim to nil. The "knock down power" you speak of will be irrelevant if all shots are placed properly at that range. Lastly, because 9mm ammo is half the price of .45 you will be more likely to go practice shooting. Your proficiency with the gun in the scenario you describe is fully dependent on your practice. Relying on "knock down power" to supplement your lack of skill with the tool is foolish.
Perfectomundo. 9mm with quality JHP ammo is all that is needed. If you want "knockdown power", then get a 12 gauge shotgun.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:27 pm to Douglas Quaid
I just noticed another good point in that post. THe FULL SIZE comment. Don't waste your time with compact unless you're planning on getting your CCW.
And still think the 9mm is only appropriate for women and men of small stature.
And still think the 9mm is only appropriate for women and men of small stature.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:28 pm to INFIDEL
No worries. We are issued Glock 22s. I just bought a Glcok 17 4th gen. For the reasons I listed minus cost of rounds. Handguns are for defense. If I go to something were someone is armed and I'm pressing the issue, I'm carrying an AR.
Posted on 2/11/12 at 5:29 pm to Douglas Quaid
While there is some merit to the 9mm suggestions in a perfect situation the 9 would do the job. But in the heat of the moment the 45 would allow you have a few bad shots and still do a lot of damage. And a full size 45 with good weigt and balance is extremely easy to manage and allows for quick follow up shots.
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News