re: What to do with 2 Old 401K accounts from previous employers

Decide who you like from existing.. then roll the other into the one you liked..

I had fidelity from the first company I worked for … I changed companies a few times in my career and would just call fidelity and give them the specifics of the other one and have them roll them together.. ( moved a Schwab.. and Merrill).. let them do it for you.. they will make sure no penalties and roll over same index funds etc …or move them into something like it that they manage..