re: What is ya'lls take on Deuce Mcallister, the RB?

quote:

---

I don’t think you ever saw Deuce play a game if you are suggesting that Ingram was in any way better than him. With All due respect to Ingram. He was definitely solid.

---

I have seen every running back the Saints have had since Michael Strachan.

Deuce and Ingram were very similar backs to me, I just think Mark was a little bit better but I could easily see someone flipping that. Ingram had the benefit of playing in the Sean Payton/Drew Brees era for the bulk of his Saints career. And since these assessments are always really subjective, I have no issues if someone thinks Duece/Thomas was better.


I think maybe you could make a good case for Pierre Thomas moving into the top two. He was never flashy but just put up rock-solid numbers his whole career. But he also benefitted from playing exclusively during the Payton/Brees era.

All 4 were great players for the Saints.