re: Jay’s Moves Look Much Better Now?

quote:

---

Then you are agreeing with me?????

Not going to plan = not done intentionally.

Or do you think JJ didn't want to have Guidry record an out and Cooper do the same? I'm not following this logic if there is one.

JJ had every intention of Guidry finishing the last 5 outs, it did not go to plan that means it wasn't intended or intentional.

Yes it worked out which is what I said, but it was not the plan intended.

---

This is the precisely the logical black hole that people are arguing from. Trying to say that he made the right decision, because the first two didn't get it done, but the last one did. Well if Jay knew that Hurd would get it done, why wasn't he warmed and ready to be the first guy in after he took Ack out?

If Thatcher was the 4th pitcher to enter in the inning, what does that say about Jay's plan? He clearly didn't plan on that sequence of events, but instead of saying "good job, Hurd", they're saying it was a great coaching decision. Well how many options did he have left? It's like trying to reason with walls around here, sometimes.