re: Has anyone tried any tobacco alternatives and what the effectiveness was?

I've tried the baccoff products, and they work to an extent. I've even tried Zyn, I know it still has nicotine, so not really a helpful quitting product. Neither has worked for me completely. I have gotten to where I won't dip in front of the wife (no pics, and yes, I know, Trashy) so that has cut down a little bit. I just think like anything else I've done, I'll quit when I quit.