Favorite team:LSU 
Location:new york city
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:3428
Registered on:3/11/2005
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
Fantastic work.

I'm a believer in having fair rules and standards. And I believe in the spirit of what college and amateur athletics should be. But everything should be fairly enforced and it's preposterous that LSU has been so forcibly threatened when other institutions have not. And in the context of your thread, there is little room for any SEC institution or its fans to clutch their pearls or throw stones-- especially not Bama.

Luis and the two football players are no more pro than any number of athletes who tried out at this pro camp or otherwise tried to matriculate into the NBA after college, whatever type of paperwork they signed or camp they attended. Signing one type of paper vs another makes zero substantive difference in terms of acquiring the significant training and experience it takes to actually become a professional player. None of them are pros in the sense of "ringers" who had extensive pro experience who were brought in surreptitiously in the distant past that required the creation of eligibility rules.

The more the hypocrisy gets air (both the BS indignation by other fanbases and the uneven treatment of the SEC office) and examples of bias are pointed out, the better.

As many have said, there hasn't been a peep out of the SEC office for Chambliss dubiously claiming a health issue at Ferris St to get another year of eligibility when he made no issue to preserve that year of eligibility while at Ferris State.

Neither has the SEC-- with their lip service to wanting to protect amateur athletes from being displaced unfairly by some of these athletes in limbo-- ever threatened Bama under Saban for chronically oversigning athletes (which I think was/is against the rules) with the intention of processing / forcing some of them to leave the team to make their numbers. That is more morally reprehensible than trying to fill holes in rosters with players in limbo who might have eligibility and who aren't pros. Letting Bama get away with that shows a blatant disregard for hopeful athletes who might have had more success at other schools if they weren't strung along and used. It was abusive and not in the spirit of protecting student athletes. And the SEC did not care one bit.

And there are countless cheating scandals which several SEC schools have been a part of which have never incurred the venom that LSU is now receiving... when it has not broken a rule. To my mind, intentionally breaking rules and cheating, which Bama, UTenn, and many other schools have blatantly been caught doing, is far worse and more disrespectful than testing the limits of rules, which LSU is currently doing, legally.
I think it is somewhat like school.

Ranking Kiffin vs other coaches before he completes a season is somewhat like comparing the academic transcript of a college graduate to a student who has one semester of credits. There's not a large enough body of work to be fair just yet.

This doesn't mean you can't have opinions and like or dislike certain attributes of his, how he runs the program, etc. But ranking him is premature.

If you want my opinion on him, I think:
- He worked really hard to implement a new system and culture at LSU. This is a work in progress.

- I think the product on the field is a little bit frustrating, similar to how post 2011 Les Miles teams were frustrating (with Miles it was lack of a passing game, with Kiffin it's lack of red zone efficiency... largely). That being said, I find both Miles and Kiffin teams to be a much more enjoyable product than Brian Kelly teams. I found BK's teams to be largely boring... and for the first time ever, under BK, found myself wondering if there were any chores I should be doing instead of watching. I never considered turning the games off this year.

- I think the boatload of money that was raised and spent is abhorrent, but is a part of the game now and we are not the only team that spent in that ~$40M+ range. Our record is what it is, but the money made us competitive in every game... Aside from a 2 game stretch of Ole Miss and Bama in 2022, LSU got blown out by almost every team with a pulse for the rest of BK's 4 year tenure.

- Kiffin has an incomplete grade imho. But I think he has the potential to establish himself and have a successful tenure here. That being said, the college football game itself is an increasingly ugly business with undesirable conference realignments, chasing TV dollars, buying players, and tampering. It's becoming more commodified, expensive, and cutthroat. The LSU loving, rich recruiting grounds that Saban saw some 25 years ago don't exist anymore. NIL $ makes it closer to the dark days of the 1990s when the blue bloods raided La. So, who knows.

re: Drone Dogs in Haiti

Posted by epbart on 11/16/26 at 10:57 pm to
quote:

The Haitians will still try and eat them.

:lol:
quote:

Outside of the money, there was an investment in playing time that you cannot really put a price. I don’t believe in sunk cost but any objective person would say there are still some interesting things there.


I don't quite understand what you're saying here (honestly), but it does remind me of something I said in another thread earlier today:

quote:

If he is demanding more money as some are saying, the above paragraph is leverage for Kiffin... Do you want to come back for your last year in a system you know and show the improvement it will take to get drafted high and and get a good pro contract, potentially several million $ more? Or do you want to gamble your NFL future for $1M-$2M of NIL money in the short term, go to another school, learn a new system, and likely fall into the later rounds?


Regarding playing time, it cuts both ways: it benefits Kiffin and Leavitt if he stays. If Leavitt stays, it's hard to imagine he won't be the starter next year unless Kiffin acquires another experienced starter that comes in and plays lights out... which is unlikely since that's another $3M-$6M. It's possible Leavitt will regress (like Marcel Reed who lost his OC), but it's more likely than not Leavitt will improve at least a little bit as a 2nd year starter. I don't follow draft grades as much as many here so this could be wrong, but I asked google about Leavitt's draft grade and it responded:
quote:

Sam Leavitt is generally projected as a first-round pick (ranging from a top-10/lottery pick to a low-end first-rounder) or a Day 1 to Day 2 prospect for the 2027 NFL Draft, depending on his continued performance and whether he declares early.


Taking that assessment at face value for the moment (I'm sure some disagree)... I think 12 INTs (with 2 games to go) and a limited deep passing game hurts him if he tries to declare early. And as I said in the ither thread, if he threatens to leave for the short term reward of $1M-$2M in NIL, it's a huge risk for him. He would have to learn a new system at another school, win the starting job, and perform better than he did this year. And he wouldn't have a 2nd year at another school to mature in the system. It should be easier to stay here, work hard and improve enough to stay a Day 1 pick. There's more risk of losing money in the draft if he leaves. It would be short-sighted, imho.


The sanity of the fan base stands upon the edge of a knife. Stray but a little and it will fail, to the ruin of all.

You must make it to Mord... err... Knoxville.
quote:


Not one of those teams have a 40 plus million dollar roster and almost a 100 million dollar head coach. Except LSU


An oft repeated argument, but not as meaningful as many think.

If we paid, say half of that, our record might be identical to what it is now with the same four losses, but I suspect we would not have been competitive in any of our losses. Under BK, we were getting blown out by Bama and UK, and likely would have been blown out vs UTx. Ole Miss is always a wild card.

The $40M class got us enough talent to compete right away and to almost win a couple of those games and to have a lead in every game. The team composition, depth, and chemistry is still a bit flawed, however.

Stability matters for continuity and chemistry. LSU (Kiffin) had to jump into the portal war late to bring in ~35 players. In comparison, Bama only had to bring in 20-25, and UGA closer to 15 (not exact numbers, but close). This matters.

It's abhorrent that we had to pay $40M. But it's too simplistic to just look at that number and assume it would pan out perfectly. Bringing in so many new pieces at the last minute based on who was available was always a gamble. It was never a guarantee.
quote:


That’s because it killed the illiterate, ill and undesirables - it didn’t lift those people up.


It also killed or imprisoned a lot of the most literate people who... I don't know... maybe had other opinions.

I suppose they would frame that as giving those people the same equitable ending as everyone else they did away with, so there's that.

re: Leavitt is a lot like Josh Booty

Posted by epbart on 11/16/26 at 12:37 pm to
Leavitt is improving, but his play frustrates me as well, and there are at least a couple WTF plays every game. I get the frustration. So I hate having to be an apologist for him today. But these kind of threads don't help anything...

Josh Booty made good plays, but also really bad plays.
Leavitt made makes good plays, but also really bad plays.
Therefore he must be benched.

If you're going to make arguments that thin, why not go all out and say:

Hitler had two legs and sometimes seemed cocky.
Leavitt also has two legs and seems cocky.
Therefore he must be taken down at any cost!!!

These type of comparative arguments people are making out of frustration recently are basically absurd syllogisms.

re: Sam Leavitt - LSU Starter Next Season

Posted by epbart on 11/16/26 at 12:16 pm to
Good posts in this thread.

I've seen the threads where people showed his underwhelming stats at Az State against 3 SEC opponents. Those stats are bad. But this year, he is throwing better than a 70% completion rate, even against better teams like Bama and UT. This shows improvement, period.

I don't know what Leavitt's ceiling is as a player. Second year starters and seniors usually improve within a stable system. If he can settle down and devote himself to film study / VR work like Burrow and Daniels, I would expect he should improve if he stays next year. His deep ball and vision/focus are his weak spots as I see it. He seems talented enough to become a very solid player. Currently, he's pretty good, but not consistent enough.

If he is demanding more money as some are saying, the above paragraph is leverage for Kiffin... Do you want to come back for your last year in a system you know and show the improvement it will take to get drafted high and and get a good pro contract, potentially several million $ more? Or do you want to gamble your NFL future for $1M-$2M of NIL money in the short term, go to another school, learn a new system, and likely fall into the later rounds?

re: Leavitt becoming a villain on campus

Posted by epbart on 11/16/26 at 10:15 am to
Not trying to pick on you specifically as you're not the only one doing this, but you're taking small anecdotes and amplifying them into massive character flaws. Projecting like this does no favor to you or others who post in this manner. It comes off as petty... "because Leavitt had some critical mistakes, we must now criticize him as a human being... we must dehumanize him!!!"

There is nothing ethical or morally superior in doing so.

quote:

They said he is becoming universally disliked by the students.

They mention lots about Sam being at the bars constantly. Some of them showed me screenshots that are going around school of Sam hitting up tons of women around campus and obviously not focusing on ball.


Going to bars as a college student!
Speaking to girls!!
The horror!!!

I understand the underlying the issues and don't disagree with those...

NIL has been abused and no college player should get paid that type of money to play college sports... no player should get $1M+ from the school or boosters if you want my opinion. The whole booster collective idea was quickly corrupted. If you are a Livvy Dunne sort and Vuori wants to sponsor you: well done and congrats! If you're a Jeremy Bloom at Colorado who had sponsorships for Olympic skiing while playing football and the ncaa made you give those up, shame on you, ncaa! If you're Leonard Fournette and want to sell shirts that say BUGA, I see no problem with it. Given that football players have to give an extra 20 hours per week of practice and likely other unsupervised workouts, etc, I don't have a problem with paying players. But it has gotten out of control.

It isn't Leavitt's fault that LSU was in a bidding war for him with UTenn and I think Miami, which led to his NIL deal. Any above average quarterback (and Leavitt is above average) in his position would take that deal. Of course, I would expect that he take that payday seriously and understand that he should work his arse off to deserve / earn it.

Going out to bars doesn't mean he isn't working his arse off otherwise. Talking to girls around campus or while out means literally nothing.

Not many kids are wired like Joe Burrow, who seemed to have zero social life and buried himself in film work. Most kids need to go out once in a while to blow off some steam. If you start hearing that Kiffin or other players say Leavitt isn't putting adequate time in the film room or skips it, that would merit putting him on blast.

quote:

I think this kid isn’t of good character nor a good representative of LSU


There is nothing you've said in this thread that merits a personal attack on his character. I can strongly disagree with you and not like what you post enough to waste my time replying to you, but you're not going to see me personally insult you anywhere in this reply. I don't know you and you don't know Leavitt.

Be as discontent as you wish. I don't like Saturday's result either and cursed under my breath at a couple of Leavitt's disastrous decisions. I'm not going to act like a belligerent travel ball parent about it, though. Nobody likes that type of negativity and self importance, desiring to belittle others. Am I a better fan though if I resort to insulting him personally?

I'm going to remain an LSU fan for the remainder of Leavitt's tenure here and after he leaves. I will hope he looks back on his time here and enjoyed the opportunity. And if... and I mean if... he isn’t doing enough film work hopefully he does have the character to refocus and put in the work to keep improving. He's improved his accuracy, but still has work to do.

re: Nanny available in Austin

Posted by epbart on 11/13/26 at 8:04 pm to
quote:

She started calling me for information instead of my wife and kept hinting at wanting to make extra money.

Guys it ain’t worth it...



Posted by AUbagman.

I don't know... but name is not really checking out, imho.
RINO was originally a pejorative term to call out moderate, socially liberal Rockefeller Republicans. Over time, post Tea Party and as MAGA came to be significant players in the R party, the target of the term became more GOPe and Bush/Cheney neocon types. It's probably an over-simplification to say this, but in some ways it became reduced to Rs who choose Wall St over Main St (internationalist interests at the expense of small biz here, outsourcing, aggressive interventionalist policies to feed the defense industry, etc.).

As I suggested in Owlfan's thread, there is some use in the term inasmuch as it might lead you to consider where a given candidate might diverge from the broader will of the the party. In truth, almost any candidate will place higher value on certain causes more than others. Some R's value religion more, others are more free economy types, others protectionist, and others will be held captive by corporate interests or whoever their backers are. So, there is some risk on overusing the term to the point of making it meaningless.

It can be hard to measure how sincere many Rs are. Sometimes, when there is a topic like voter security which has near universal Repubican voter backing (as well as a lot of Dems), a character like Thune, who seemed to have no interest in backing Trump's agenda, reveals himself to be someone who is not just not pro-Trump, but against the will of the voters who elected him. This (a pattern of action against the voters who elected you) is perhaps one of the biggest tells that someone is a RINO. All Republicans might do this once in a while, whether out of deliberate action or as a concession for something else. With some, however, the pattern of constantly speaking to voters one way and acting another reveals a deeper level of being disingenuous which merits the RINO label.

re: Is Trump a RINO?

Posted by epbart on 11/13/26 at 2:26 pm to
quote:

Is Trump a RINO?


Yes and no.

His positions, I suspect, overlap with the older faction of Rockefeller Republicans of the 1990s and earlier (when the term RINO was first used if I'm not mistaken). He was a Democrat at that time, but I would imagine he got along with the coastal R's well enough... and probably did not strongly agree with the religious right too much at that point in time. This is a guess. His positions may have changed between then and now, though there are some interviews from the 1980s in which his positions don't sound too far off from what he ran on in 2016.

After the Left and establishment Right sort of mitigated the success of the Tea Party, the populist movement regrouped under Trump's direction, and the term RINO pointed more to establishment R's and the Bush/Cheney neocon faction. In this regard, no, Trump is not a RINO.

If you want my opinion on Trump, I think he sincerely ran on an America First agenda as a Republican after he attempted to run on the same platform as a Democrat and they refused to give him a voice; the socialist and internationalist factions in the Democrat party were too far advanced post-Obama for an America First message to get oxygen. Based on the fact that he expressed any interest in running as a Democrat, it is fair to say he is a RINO... though I'd say it's more fair to call him an America First moderate.

If you want to measure RINO as campaigning like you're going to do the will of the Rebublican voters, but then ignoring the will of the people once you're in office, I don't think the label RINO sticks at all. I think he wanted to govern in accordance with his campaign promises. He just had to fight not only the Dems, media, activist NGOs and judges, but the establishment and neocon Republicans as well (those who more easily fit the RINO label), who refused to pass his most meaningful plans into law.

There is some usefulness in terms like RINO. It can help a person to pause and consider where a give politican may diverge from the party and why that might be: loyalty to a certain cause or region over the party, being beholden to a certain corporate interest, etc. That usefulness, however, has its limits. As an analogy, within the Catholic Church, many members-- cafeteria Catholics-- adhere to some ideas of the Church while disbelieving or acting in opposition to others. At what point do you consider such a person a Catholic in name only? It becomes a slippery slope when you want to just wag your finger and call someone a sinner, heretic, etc. We're all sinners after all.

People can be more complicated than a label. That doesn't mean they lack integrity in context of being a Republican or whatever... though sometimes it does.
Whatever issues Peterson might've gone through, h is correct in principle on this point: to be peaceful, a man must be capable of doing harm; otherwise, he is not peaceful (or virtuous), he is just harmless.

... in meme form...





quote:

You better synergize lest they circle back and optimize your arse.


Synergy sounds like boomer / Gen X speak. I'm not sure I vibe with that.

re: Redirects to scare pages

Posted by epbart on 11/11/26 at 10:41 pm to
I'm getting the redirect to a scareware page tonight (Nov 11).

Has happened twice now. I click on a thread and as I read the posts, a new page launches / redirects to a page saying something about my galaxy s23 is compromised and to run a scan. I hit the back button and closed the tab and didn't press anything on that page of course.

When I switched from Chrome to Firefox on my phone this evening, it did not happen. When I switched back to Chrome it happened again.
quote:

That's why the expectation is and rightfully so is to start winning from year 1. Back in the day when Nick Saban had the same guys for 6 years and they had no hope of making money or getting into the NFL if they didn't get their act together, sure, give that time. But leavitt and the like are getting paid 5 million THIS YEAR. No one is saying lane should be fired. But the expectation is to win, and yes, right out the gate. No excuses with Texas, just figure it out


That's almost, but not quite, rational.

Stability and continuity of the core of a team still matters. I asked google for a summary of roster turnover for LSU and to compare it to Bama & UGA. Here is what it states:

LSU:
~35 lost to portal
~30 gained through portal
Note: High volatility (forced complete rebuild/retooling under Kiffin)

Bama:
23 lost
20 gained
note: Moderate (yearly talent churn, managed via elite depth)

UGA:
17 lost
9 gained
note: High stability (minimal portal reliance, system continuity)

So, yes, everyone leans on the portal, but the more a given program's system is effectively in place and stable enough to encourage player retention (if you're an elite program with upside), the less you need to lean on the portal.

Kiffin was never going to get everyone he wanted when top programs are bidding for the same players. He still did a great job with the limited time he had to work with and with the available players. It was always going to be a huge rebuild project.

The $40M - $50M price tag fooled some into thinking they "should be" contenders, but it was always going to be a gamble as to which players would step up in a new environment and system and how quickly the team would gel. All things considered, LSU admin, Kiffin & his staff, etc. have done a good job. It just sucks that it cost this much money to jump start the program under Kiffin.

re: Leavitt and year 2 with LK

Posted by epbart on 11/9/26 at 10:21 am to
Experience always matters.

Different players, of course, have different ceilings as to their potential.

Given Leavitt's improvements over this season (after missing last year and spring camp), I'm not sure he's reached his ceiling yet. I don't expect him to develop into Joe Montana or Joe Burrow, but there is no indication that I see to suggest he has plateaued or regressed at this point. He does have some aspects to his game that I hope will improve.

quote:

I voted twice for Trump. Its whatever.


You say that like it's some great feat. It is indeed whatever.

quote:

Both times he didnt do shite while he had control of the H&S. Both times lost control.


He tried to advance his agenda with both houses of Congress. Neither the House nor Senate Republicans had any real interest in helping him do so. They gave lip service to some of it, but undermined him every time it mattered most. I don't blame him for that.

Because Congress backstabbed him so much, Trump had to work through executive orders a lot more than should have been necessary. This opened him more to being stalled or stymied by NGOs and their complicit activist judges in a way Congress could have helped him avoid.

quote:

JD Vance hated Trump, then all of the sudden he was on his team. Smdh.


Sometimes enemies become friends. Sometimes people who get divorced get married a second time if they think they resolved their differences. And sometimes people you think are your friends end up betraying you. Sad, but the world be like that...FRFR.

quote:

JD Vance hated Trump, then all of the sudden he was on his team. Smdh.


They did hang out at times in the past. And people like Senator Gillibrand had no problem hitting Trump up for money before he ran for President. Once he was elected, their relationship changed, as sometimes happens. It really do be like that.

quote:

Trump used to be a democrat for decades. Let that sink in for second.


Sigh... do we need to go over how some things change again? ... including how Democrats didn't all hate the United States the way they do now. The current Democrat party would kick out many Democrats from previous decades, like Larry McDonald from Georgia.

quote:

His terms were one big pysop.


Maybe, but I don't see it that way. For clarity, there were psyops all over the place. I don't attribute those to him. Establishment Republicans just joined with the Dems to thwart his ability to get things done.

quote:

The official "we all got fricked in the arse" by the dems has been completed.


Sorry, kid. It's not completed yet. That part is still down the road, but it is coming.


... well, I would say this has been fun, but I'm not sure you really said much. The more I think about it, I find your post to be kind of psyop-ish and I think I just wasted my time, which is so... whatever.

Peace.
quote:

Because no matter who is in power, they'll screw it up. Dems will over compensate, and not deliver what the American people really want and they'll have another 2010, 2016, 2024 - its like clockwork.


In recent decades, the scewing up part seems to be design, slowly demoralizing us enroute to the crisis phase... as Bezmenov said.

I think someone on here or on X-- can't remember who or I'd give them credit-- made an observation that it's not so much a pendulum as you're suggesting, with one side screwing up and going too far one way, then the other side going too far the other way. It's more like a ratchet: the Left swings us one way and does damage / tightens institutional control. When the Right swings back the other way, they don't undo the damage of the swing to the Left. It's a rather hollow (maybe loud, but ineffectual) swing to the right that simply sets the levers of control in a position where the Left regains power and cinches down again with more force and greater control.

Being too high or low over the results is irrelevant. Accepting the results is fine if one is content to follow where they want to lead us... a topic of many prior threads on here. Not accepting it means personal change towards greater understanding of the topics and towards being a more moral person as the founders suggested... and it will take enough people developing such a will to effect change in a meaningful way.