Favorite team:Notre Dame 
Location:Ireland
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:77
Registered on:2/8/2022
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
quote:

Even at ND he was making around $3 million a year.


By the time he left Notre Dame his annual total compensation package was in the region of $7.5m.

re: Brian Kelly hate

Posted by Irish ND fan on 10/19/25 at 2:45 pm to
quote:

Not to mention that ND lost to Bowling Green. And has been an embarrassment this year.


Notre Dame has never lost to Bowling Green. They've only ever played once in football, in 2019, and the Irish won 52-0.

I'm not sure what's embarrassing this year about losing two close games to quality opponents early in the season and then being 5-2 and ranked #12 with five winable games to go. :dunno:
quote:

Who names their kid Boo?

Someone who's a big fan of 'To Kill A Mockingbird'?
Presumably because none of you wanted to be 'in the North'?
quote:

2023 SEC Rushing leaders:

8. Montrell Johnson
10. Trevor Etienne
12. Logan Diggs
13. Dylan Sampson


What happened with Logan Diggs at LSU? He looked very promising in his Freshman year at Notre Dame, before transferring home. Last I noticed, he had transferred again to Ole Miss.
quote:

Notre Dame will likely be a 14-20 point favorite.

The only early line I could find had ND -12.5.

If the Irish can start 2-0 at Miami FL and at home to A&M, and Arkansas struggle a bit, I could easily see it heading towards 17.

Redshirt FR, CJ Carr, will likely be the starting QB for Notre Dame. Highly touted, very good in practice, but yet to face a meaningful live snap. Could do with a Joe Moore Award-finalist OL in front of him hopefully.
quote:

Notre Dame was Adidas for the longest time until recently when they switched

The Irish were with Adidas for 16 years, then moved to Under Armor back in 2014. The uniforms are fine but by all accounts there are regular complaints about the quality of the footwear.
quote:

Auburn would have played Notre Dame in the Sugar Bowl for the natty and we would have beaten them. They were good, but that wishbone wouldn't have worked against us and they weren't prepared for SEC athletes in the Superdome. Pat Dye wins a natty and we build momentum.


The 1988 Notre Dame National Championship team beat #2 Miami, #4 Michigan, #5 West Virginia and #7 USC (all rankings at season end) en route to the title. If the 12-0 Irish could overcome the speed of Miami, then the fastest team in CFB, then they could certainly have coped with 10-2 Auburn.
quote:

If the Tigers don't make the CFP this season, BK is gone. Adios Amigo.
He will not be fired, but will either retire or voluntarily resign with a Settlement.
GTFO with all that "3 more Years" BS.


Given that he's contractually due 90% of his remaining salary, if he is fired, why on earth would he even consider retiring (and passing up over $50m) or voluntarily resigning and settling for anything less than his guaranteed amount?

If asked to consider a settlement by LSU, would he and/or his agent not just say 'we already negotiated the 'settlement' when we signed the original contract: 90% of whatever salary is still left on the contract'?
Tom Zibkowski against USC in the 'Bush Push' game in '05.


LINK
Luke Kuechly would have committed to Notre Dame in a heartbeat had they offered him. Charlie Weis's staff didn't think we was good enough.

re: Texas A&M 2025 Projection

Posted by Irish ND fan on 6/28/25 at 3:44 pm to
quote:

Crud, will do so now


DE, Boubacar Traore, may well be ND's best DL player this coming season. DT will be by committee. There is no one outstanding player there, but a lot of depth - more so than I can remember in my 25 years following the team.

re: Texas A&M 2025 Projection

Posted by Irish ND fan on 6/26/25 at 5:51 am to
quote:

Game to game breakdown, 70% chance of making the playoffs. Check out the article:

LINK


"Critical Player Matchups:
A&M C Faaiu/Nabou vs. ND DT Howard Cross III: This is the premier interior battle. Cross's elite ratings suggest he will be disruptive, capable of getting penetration and forcing A&M's run plays to bounce outside, making them less efficient. The model gives Cross the advantage in over 60% of their one-on-one snaps."

"Game Synopsis & Path to Victory: A&M must embrace a "chaos" approach. Their path to victory involves abandoning the run game early if it's not working and putting the game in Marcel Reed's hands. They need to use designed QB runs and rollouts to get him outside the pocket, away from Howard Cross III. They must turn this into an unstructured backyard football game. Notre Dame's path is simpler: stop the run, contain the QB, and win a low-scoring, 20-17 type of game. The hostile environment and ND's trench advantage make that the more likely outcome."


You may want to re-draft your analysis of the A&M at Notre Dame game in week 3. Howard Cross III signed with the Cincinnati Bengals as an UDFA shortly after the 2025 NFL draft. Last season was his final year of college eligibility.
quote:

Notre Dame has done this the past 3 years while waiting on their near 5 star rated QB to develop last year.

FWIW ND has gone with a one-year portal rental QB is three of the last four seasons. Jack Coan (Wisconsin) in '21, Sam Hartman (Wake Forest) in '23 and Riley Leonard (Duke) in '24.

In '22 they started Tyler Buchner and then when he got injured in the fourth quarter of the second game of the year, they had to start Drew Pyne for the rest of the regular season. Alabama and Missouri fans will understand how well that didn't go.

This year should see the winner of the competition between RS SO, Kenny Minchey and RS FR, CJ Carr. The latter is the favourite. That would hopefully give two full seasons of a home-grown QB. After that, we'll see.
quote:

Diaco was BK’s DC at ND at one point. Forgot he was on staff here.

He won the Broyles Award in 2012 when he was DC of the Notre Dame team that went to the National Championship Game.
There's been six college football games in Dublin this century. Navy played Notre Dame back in 2012, then in 2014 Penn State played UCF, and in 2016 Georgia Tech played Boston College.

Notre Dame were supposed to play Navy in 2020 but that was cancelled due to the Covid lockdowns, and rearranged for three years later.

Since 2022 they've had the 'Aer Lingus College Football Classic' each Week 0 to start the season. In 2022 it was Nebraska-Northwestern, in 2023 Notre Dame-Navy and in 2024 Florida State-Georgia Tech.

In 2025 it's scheduled to be Iowa State-Kansas State in Farmaggedon, and in 2027 it's Pittsburgh-Wisconsin. All of these games, with the exception of the 2014 one, have been at the Aviva Stadium, the home of the Ireland soccer and rugby national teams, which has a capacity for college football of around 47,000. (If and when an NFL game, likely a Pittsburgh Steelers game, is played here, it will almost certainly be at the 82,000 capacity Croke Park, Ireland's national (GAA) stadium).

The current series of games are sponsored by Ireland's national airline, Aer Lingus, and supported by the Irish government. They basically pay the teams to come over here to help promote tourism to Ireland. Most of the tickets that go to US fans are sold via travel packages that usually involve at least a five day stay. And if you like golf, there's the option for an awful lot of that.

They've already had Notre Dame (several times), a Big Ten team, ACC teams and this coming summer Big 12 teams. I understand that they would love to bring over an SEC team, and given that Brian Kelly was here in 2012 (and involved in the planning for the 2020 game that never came to pass) it was an obvious avenue to explore with him.

Plus LSU is one of the SEC teams that is historically open to playing week 0 neutral site games (though I appreciate that recent results in them understandably impact fans' views on their suitability). If they do bring an SEC team over then I expect it would be against either a G5 or lower level P4 team.

Given the capacity of the Aviva Stadium, and the fact that the last two games have sold out, I can't see LSU-ND ever happening, as both fan bases are just too big when combined together. ND took a record 40,000 fans here in 2022 and LSU I would imagine could bring 20,000-30,000 at least, so the organisers would rather bring them both, if they could, but in different years.

I'd say you'd be more likely to see something like LSU-Memphis. LSU-Houston, or LSU-Purdue than an all SEC game with LSU, or LSU-ND, if it were to happen. The earliest it could happen is August 2026; if not then, then 2028 is the next open date.

quote:

Because he has expressly said he doesn't want to coach in the NFL.


He must have changed his tune then. Back in 2012 he interviewed with the Philadelphia Eagles for their open HC position while he was in the middle of preparing his ND team for the national championship game against Bama.
quote:

Favorites are 10-0 straight up


That's not actually true. Favourites are 9-1 straight up.

Although Notre Dame opened as -1.5 point favourites over Penn State, by kickoff the line was Penn State -1.5. The Irish were the first underdog to win a game in the new twelve-team playoff.

And hopefully the second.
quote:

Then theyre as dumb as you are. LSU nuked ND back to the stone age, when they had Samardjiza and Quinn in that Sugar Bowl. They wallowed in mediocrity and fired coaches like it was a sport itself.


Notre Dame has never 'fired coaches like it was a aport itself'. Even in the lean period between Lou Holtz's final season (1996) and Brian Kelly's first (2010), they only had three different coaches. Bob Davie (97-01) and Charlie Weis (05-09) both got five years in the post, and Tyrone Willingham (02-04) is the only Irish coach in the last 60 years who didn't make it to year 5, and that's because of how immeasurably lazy and poor he was as a recruiter (Washington discovered this to their cost when they subsequently appointed him and he led them to a 0-12 season).


quote:

Also, the ND of today isn't the same one Kelly left. His leaving is what finally got their admin to relax admissions for football players, then you add in the transfer portal and NIL, and what you get is a completely different program than the one Kelly left.


Admissions have not been relaxed significantly. And the transfer portal has made little difference. Almost all ND's transfers are grad transfers who they could have gotten/did get in the previous era. It's still very hard for ND to get underclassmen transfers admitted, which is why they rarely go down that route. (It's no coincidence that Hartman and Leonard were grad transfers).

The only difference with transfers is the volume. It used to be one or two, now it's more in the 7-9 range, but Freeman still wants to focus primarily on HS recruiting and use transfers to top up areas of weakness. You'll never see ND go down the route of bringing in 15-25 transfers in one off-season.

Where the key difference to Kelly's ND era is, is NIL. ND don't get much publicity for how they use NIL but by all accounts they are very competitive in this area. They tend not to get into a lot of bidding wars for transfer players (except at QB, when needed) but pay their existing roster very well to try to atop them transferring.

quote:

Despite all that, he is still a far better coach coach and program builder than anyone ND has had in over a century, as evidenced by the fact that he is their all-time winningest coach,


He is also their losingest coach in history. He has more wins AND more losses than any ND coach ever. Which the more discerning observers will realise is primarily a product of his length of service.

He's not even near the top five coaches in program history. Knute Rockne (3), Frank Leahy (4), Ara Parseghian (2), Dan Devine (1), Lou Holtz (1) all have national championships and statues outside Notre Dame Stadium. Rockne and Parseghian in particular were better program builders as well FWIW.

quote:

he is still in a much better position to win a national championship here at LSU.

Kelly will win a natty at LSU, Freeman wont win 1 anywhere.


We shall see. That's what makes the sport such fun.