Favorite team:New Orleans Saints 
Location:
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:1000
Registered on:1/20/2018
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
Good stuff. You are definitely a value-add around here and know your stuff. I wasn’t trying to imply you were coming off as arrogant - just a little over optimistic given some of the uncertainty with the personnel in this DL group. I do believe there’s a good chance that what you have predicted comes to fruition.

I’m very intrigued with Steve M and the impact he can have. I think Beaman will also be a big time player for us (would have helped us out in a major way last year if not for injury).
quote:

2. James Smith did not fit in an Odd Front and his lack of length limited him to strictly playing a 3-tech

quote:

Updated weights in Alabama's D-line room entering fall camp:

Terrance Green - 313
Steve Bolo Mboumoua - 303
Kedrick Bingley-Jones - 302
Jeremiah Beaman - 301
London Simmons - 300
Devan Thompkins - 300
Edric Hill - 292
Isaia Faga - 291
Leslie Black - 290
Mhari Johnson - 290
Corey Howard - 288
Nolan Wilson - 285
Caleb Smith - 280
Malique Franklin - 275
Fatutoa Henry - 272

James Smith last year was listed at 6’3” 296. Top 15 recruit nationally coming out of high school. Was consistently good up front with flashes of game wrecking ability (was hoping he would have a better motor / play with consistent high-effort). Ohio State, which has a loaded DL, wanted him badly.

If James Smith does not or did not “fit” in CKW’s front, which of the guys listed above does? As RiseUp said, we have a ton of unknowns on the DL going into this year. The “knowns” we do have on the roster have not exactly set the stat sheets on fire, whether here or at their former schools.

You like to tout stats from our top-2 SEC defense last year, and extrapolate that to definitively say we will upgrade this upcoming season, yet you never mention the actual dudes who were on the field that played a massive part in the success we had last year defensively - and all but one or two of the contributors in the front seven last year are no longer with this program.

I do think the DL could be pretty damn good this year, but it is far from the certainty you continually propagate on this board. Several players up front have to step up in a big, big way for the DL to achieve the expectations that you have.

You bring some good Xs and Os content to the board and drive discussion, which is nice to see. But seems to me you are too wrapped up in what we have “on paper” (particularly based on measurables), because the production from the guys we have in the DL room this year does not reflect an upgraded DL room for 2026, and our depth is largely unproven potential that has logged very few, if any, SEC snaps.

But I love your optimism and will gladly come back in the Fall and admit you were right and I have no clue what I’m talking about if that is how things play out.
quote:

Guys like Keeley, Smith, Renaud, K. Collins, etc were essentially unplayable in the bigger front CKW transitioned to…that’s why they were all processed and replaced with much bigger bodies in the offseason.

Did Saban not recruit all of these guys to play in an… odd front?
quote:

Also yes, the issue for BLM was specifically about a racial group being selectively targeted by law enforcement.

Just go look at the BLM official website. The official website of the foundation points to the pillars of the movement being far more than “specifically about a racial group being selectively targeted by LE”.

If it was just about “selective targeting by LE”, why did people march/protest/riot in the name of BLM over Ahmaud Arbery, who was tragically murdered, but not by active duty LE? Seems BLM stepped outside of their lane on this one.

Show me one BLM protest that was prompted by a black citizen being murdered by a black police officer. This is what I was alluding to when stating that they only protest when it involved a black victim and white LEO. You are the smooth brain rambling about “all lives matter” and the poverty cycle.
quote:

Well the creators of BLM didn't really care about "black lives" no differently than some of you or the others in the far right.

Their moto was literally destroying family, community and other core traditions because chaos could create what they really were targeting; children, broken homes and other deviant behaviors and ideals.

They per usual in history just used black people to get to their goal.

That however is different from black people protesting against police brutality.

Even though we all know they used this to further their own desires.

This is exactly what I was getting at with my post. Couldn’t agree more. BLM - the organization and a large part of the movement - had very little to do with the betterment of our black communities. BLM - just like the MeToo movement and so many other preceding movements - was a Trojan Horse to sow social discord. And to fraudulently funnel cash to a select few.

quote:

didn't really care about "black lives" no differently than some of you or the others in the far right.

Hold up, you’re gonna single out the “far right” but give a pass to the “far left” and the democrat backers and enablers of the BLM leadership, who stole funds and hijacked the movement for personal gain? Again, the people that “don’t care” are bad, but those that are using the movement for nefarious reasons… crickets?

You’re almost there - so, so close. But it seems that your inherent racism prevents you from seeing what, and who, the real problem is. I pray for you, brother. Look at the individual; group identity is for the stupid.
quote:

The BLM movement wasn’t a lie
substantial financial fraud involving the leadership of the BLM organization says otherwise. The BLM movement mobilizing only when a black life was lost at the hands of a white perp, but not whenever a black life was lost, points to the “movement” largely being a massive lie.. though there were definitely some idiots that were duped into thinking it was a legitimate cause.
I’m aware. “Early-to-mid Saban era” was explicitly said in the last paragraph of the post.

Yes, it tailed off when he was ~70 years old, but are you suggesting that Alabama football under Nick Saban did not largely dominate the SEC, and the sport as a whole?


quote:

This year the run game will be improved

It should be, because as you said - it was abysmal last year. No improvement or worse results in the run game relative to last year would be a disaster for CKD.

quote:

No it won't be '2008 ground and pound until they submit' but it will be serviceable that I can guarantee you

Love the positive outlook, but that is a very optimistic assumption. I hope you’re right. The OL/RBs will need to improve dramatically to get to a “serviceable” run game level in SEC play this year.
My main question about a DeBoer-led program at this point is consistency. Going back to his last year at Washington, it seems like every squad he has fielded going back to that team has played up and down to the level of competition.

This is the primary thing that made Saban as great as he was IMO, and what has spoiled a large portion of the fanbase. Under Saban, the Tide came out of the tunnel and did “their thing” and it was never about the guys in the other jerseys.

DeBoer’s squads, for whatever reason, appear to have major issues with consistency not only on a game-to-game basis but sometimes even on a drive-to-drive/play-to-play basis.

I understand the game/roster management situation is entirely different from the early-to-mid Saban era, and the current format makes consistency infinitely more difficult to achieve, but this is where I’d like to see DeBoer grow in his role as a program manager.

re: WTF is Walmart up to?

Posted by Hawaiian Punch on 5/9/26 at 3:37 pm to
quote:

Walmart is controlled by some bad people. They are also very political and part of the corrupt system. They stopped carrying Mike Lindell's products simply because he was a vocal, high-profile supporter of President Trump

To say this,
quote:

There's 2 things I do that I dont feel good about. One is that I mostly shop at Wal-mart because 1) they're very close to me, and 2) they carry everything, unlike much smaller stores like Dollar General. I actually like Dollar General, but they are small stores and don't sell everything.

The 2nd thing I do that I don't feel good about is Amazon. I don't trust Amazon, but they are so darn convenient.

And then this? Buy directly from the supplier if it’s proprietary. Or man up and make it yourself. You sound like my almost certainly gay liberal cousin.
quote:

Even if he just came to play for Saban you still should have some loyalty to your teammates and some pride in your legacy instead of just being a mercenary

I agree with this in principle, but it’s not always so cut and dry. For example a guy like Jaheim Oatis. While he turned out to be a dud, had he been an NFL-level type talent but wasn’t going to play much under the new regime (not CKD & Co. specifically, just in general) due to scheme, or be utilized in a way that promoted his development, at what point should he just sacrifice his career and potential livelihood for “brotherhood”?

That said, this was not the case with Downs. And turns out Mo Linguist is a pretty damn good coach that looks like he will put players in the league regularly. Downs would have thrived in this defense.

Edit:
Of the teammates he left high and dry, I want to know which ones stayed without asking for a dollar/pay bump.
“From all reports”, it sounds like we should have some quality competition/depth on defense.

DL: Thompkins, Green and Simmons to start, with Ed Hill, Steve Mboumoua, Faga and Beaman to spell them is very solid on paper. Beaman was supposed to be a key contributor last year before going down for the year vs FSU. I’ve got pretty high hopes for him and Steve M. Faga has created some buzz this offseason and last - high motor guy. The Bandit group probably gives me the most worry of the spots across the front.

Wolf/OLB: Pierre is a known. Justin Hill looks to be a VERY good player too. The freshmen Matthews is a big kid and has lots of potential. Other freshman Xavier Griffin likely to get looks at OLB in pass rush situations as well.

ILB: I see Woodson and Reese as “starters” but competition is intense in this room. Metz and Sanders have gotten a lot of reps and apparently have shined. Duke Johnson, Cayden Jones and Xavier Griffin are wild cards here. I feel any combination of these guys have a “serviceable” floor.

CBs: strong across the board. Zabien and Lee Jr may be the best tandem in CFB this year. Strong “starter quality” depth behind them.

Husky: Red Morgan is experienced and a pretty damn good player. I’ve seen Mincey and McDonald mentioned here as well. Mincey was quietly a solid player for us last year. Jireh Edwards likely to be involved here as well.

FS/SS: Sabb and Hubbard is great starting point here. We know what we have with them. Taylor will for sure see action at one of the two spots this year. Dre K Jr. a wild card here who could earn some minutes. Same with Jireh Edwards but if he’s taking reps from the aforementioned, this guy is likely a first round NFL draft pick type talent at safety.

All in all, I feel good about the defense. Wommack and that group need to show out this year. I like his scheme/philosophy overall, but I’m not crazy about the Bandit position; Regularly dropping a 265+ lb pass rush guy in space or to the flat is… stupid. Having Dez Zulu line up at 3/4i is a recipe for disaster. Saw it multiple times in ADay.
quote:

JD Pickell

Is a watered down version of Josh Pate. Should not put much stock into what either has to say.

This Bama squad will be interesting. We’ve got some good talent for sure, but how intense and tough are they? We haven’t been tough and mean(!) on the OL or DL since like 2020 (really since 2017 for the DL).

Can’t have Ryan Williams being scared of contact or making a tough play over the middle.

RBs need to step up and crush blitzing rushers.

I want the OL to finish blocks every play and make the opponents’ Saturdays a four quarter living nightmare. If an opposing defender cheap shots our QB after the whistle, Michael Carroll & Co. better go to war on the field right then and there.

It’s a new regime and this is a young team. We need some mean as frick junkyard dawgs to step up and lead this team, and set the bar for everyone else. Do we have guys like that? I don’t know.
quote:

Keelon's pocket presence concerned me.

That is just how he plays, similar to BY and Tua. The dude can pull up and let it rip on a dime; he uses his legs to draw the defense up and will weigh his passing options downfield until the last possible second - see ULM live game film from last year.

quote:

Reminded me of Manziel dancing around in the backfield in terms of footwork quality.

Are you talking about Heisman trophy winner Johnny Manziel? The one who made Nick Saban’s defense look silly two years in a row? I’ll take it.

quote:

The seam throw to Meadows

I’ve only seen highlights of the seam throw to CD Morgan, which couldn’t have been better and would have been completed in a real game even with the rush. Can you link the throw down the seam to Meadows?

quote:

and that touchdown over the DB on the sideline (one where the db jumped 5 yards forward for no reason)

This is probably a valid take. He was late getting that one out. Likely would have been sacked, or on the run for his life at a minimum.
quote:

0 and 6 will never be SEC RB's.

Way too early to tell on #0.

Agree in that #6 should not be a feature back for us.
Probably Junior JD (or his first year at LSU) in year 1, in relative command much of the year with some plays overestimating his abilities and flashes that make your jaw drop. Once he settles in mentally and things slow down for him, you will be watching a NFL first round pick.
Their legs made those guys so dynamic, but their ability to throw accurately on the run was the real game changer. I believe Russell has “it”. Will take some time to develop with processing and reaction speed, but this dude looks like he will be a great one.

But again, this team will go as far as the OL and DLs allow. Have to be “very good” in both those rooms at a minimum to do anything as a team this year (every year).
Keelon looks like he will be special. If he is comfortable back there in SEC play, watch out.. Jayden Daniels 2.0.

Can’t take too much away from a scrimmage. My biggest question going into the season is how physical are we on OL & DL. Still no clue what we have there. Justin Hill, QB Reese and Woodson look like players. We have talent; we need the intensity and toughness to compliment it, and we will be really solid this year.
And by the grace of God, we are all fortunate enough to have YStar’s infinite wisdom showered upon this board.


Dude’s a legend in his own mind
quote:

Yeah, I was looking at our transfers just now, and figured he's the most likely candidate. He looks imposing.

quote:

He looks imposing

Fifth from the left in the crimson UA shirt (I think it’s TF Corey Howard) is also built like a freak.
quote:

Look at the list of True Freshmam LBs that started under CNS: - Rolando McClain
- Donte Hightower
- Reggie Ragland
- CJ Mosely
- Christian Harris (played Cornerback as a Senior at University Lab (1A) in Baton Rouge
- Trey Depriest (injury wrecked his career)
- Dylan Moses (same)
- Rashaad Evans
Many others who played a lot as well:
- Jihaad Campbell (rotated with Trez Marshal/was start in Semi-Final game vs Michigan)
- Reuben Foster (making the calls was the only reason he didn’t start day 1)

And these guys have what to do with Xavier Griffin?

These guys listed were coached by some of the best defensive minds in the game - some of these defensive coaches being historically great. That is no longer the situation in Tuscaloosa.

CJ Mosley 2.0 is a big frickin ask too. You think Griffin will be one of the best ILBs in the conference (which is incredibly watered down, particularly from a defensive standpoint, compared to when Mosley was in TTown) on Day 1?

Look, I think X. Griffin will be a good player for us at some point, but a lot of your takes are overly optimistic to the point of delusion.