re: The Wall and Abortion - just go with it..

quote:

---

Wall would be contraceptives

quote:

---

Agree.

---

abortion would be deportation.

quote:

---

But is it really?

---

Isn't the correct analogy for abortion in this case execution as a punishment for illegal immigration?

I mean, deported is implicitly still alive, no?

---

if we really want to work this analogy thoroughly, it would probably be more accurate to say that “border security“ is the analog of “birth control.”

The GOP wants to focus upon Physical barriers (abstinence only), while the Dems want to focus upon other forms of border security (which would include birth control, efucation and yes abortion).

The Dems don’t mind throwing a few dollars at that abstinence (ports of entry, border patrol, etc.), but they do not see it as the best primary approach. The GOP is happy to throw money at the Dems’ ideas (except abortion) but want to focus on abstinence.

quote:

---

if we really want to work this analogy thoroughly, it would probably be more accurate to say that “border security“ is the analog of “birth control.” The GOP wants to focus upon Physical barriers (abstinence only), while the Dems want to focus upon other forms of border security (which would include birth control, efucation and yes abortion). The Dems don’t mind throwing a few dollars at that abstinence (ports of entry, border patrol, etc.), but they do not see it as the best primary approach. The GOP is happy to throw money at the Dems’ ideas (except abortion) but want to focus on abstinence.

---

Not accurate. Trump's plan includes more agents and tech as well.

quote:

---

Trump's plan includes more agents and tech as well.

---

In the other thread, I was told that this wouldn't happen. We wouldn't need to keep spending money on it and CBP wouldn't benefit from an increase in spending...

First I would have to agree that the wall is similar to abstinence. I don't.

And anyway if the wall IS similar to abstinence, it would work by itself.

How many women get pregnant without insemination? I'll guess 0.

quote:

---

Depends on what you want "work" to mean. Does it prevent pregnancy? Sure. It would also prevent the survival of humanity.

---

There you go again....

Confusing wanted pregnancies with unwanted pregancies.

Sounds familiar.

Never heard of a women having her wanted pregancy aborted for birth control.

I think you have went off the rails.

You understand there is legal immigration and illegal immigration.

You understand there is wanted pregnancies and unwanted pregancies.

Stop trying to lump them together. They are different.

You're combining two things that are different. That's cheating.

quote:

---

more "morale" solution

---

quote:

---

I don't even know

---

Obviously.