re: Time for Sean P to go

How many NFL coaches have coached currently for 8+ years with the same team? Numbers are skewed a lot by stuff like this.

The list I looked at showed current teams, and usually a coach doesn't come into a good situation

So 6 out of 32 currently makes you elite?

How can you even say that isn't elite? All of these Coaches have won a SB (besides SF Harbaugh) in the past 5 years. Being put in that category means you are elite...

quote:

---

What is it that you want me to read? Is your message encrypted within what you're actually saying? You said he's considered elite, and I don't consider being 6th elite

---

I said he's widely considered to be an elite coach.

Is he not widely considered to be an elite coach? He's near the top of every list, specifically when asked of the players and coaches who actually play the game

Also, Tom Coughlin comes in at 13th overall...

I would argue that most of those people don't know what elite means

I question if you even know what elite is.

quote:

---

I would argue that most of those people don't know what elite means

---

quote:

---

Much like the "QB Tiers" project published earlier in the offseason, I asked what I consider a balanced range of informed voters -- eight current general managers, four former GMs, four personnel directors, four executives, six coordinators and four position coaches -- to provide a 1-5 rating for every head coach. Bill Belichick led the way with 28 votes in the first tier, followed by Pete Carroll (23) and Sean Payton (22). No one else commanded more than a dozen top-tier votes, drawing a clear line after these three coaches in the eyes of the 30 insiders. But another half-dozen coaches were not too far behind, and there were surprises along the way.

---

Sounds elite

Why are we only looking at 5 years?