re: NFL top QB's...

i felt the need to put Eli in there somewhere but I can't stand that mother fricker

This is a Saints board where FANS come to talk about their favorite team. You along with these other newcomers can only try to talk negative shite on a consistent basis about a team on a FAN FORUM in an effort to cause constant conflict by picking out the most controversial and best aspects/players of this team and talking ridiculous bullshite. Do you really expect to make some off the wall stupid fricking thread about a player/team here and get some equal or agreeable response? frick no. You get what you get everyday. Arguements, cut downs, non football related responses. Because your intent is to piss in peoples cornflakes that's why. Then you get all upset and rant and rave because you are the center of all negative remarks.

Look boy, I've got a wealth of football knowledge and post great remarks and good convo to all the "normal fans" during the season on here and throughout TC, preseason etc...

Right now we all just have to grin and bear all the dumbfrick jackasses like you (and others) that are looking for conflict on a daily basis.

quote:

---

whodatfan

---

+1.75 Trillion

Chad is what keeps TD from being SR. You don't have to agree with anyone's opinion, simply state your own and compare. The minute anyone starts letting someone else's opinion make you want to stab a baby with a straightened fish hook is when you need to take a step back and say this slowly...internet...message board...it's going to be okay!

you wanna go motherfricker? lets dance.

quote:

---

I've seen more from Rodgers than i have from these guys. And my ratings are coming from what i see these guys do with the ball in their hands, not what their running game does to win the games for them. I do see your point, they (rodgers & cassel) both have 1 year starting under their belt. The difference is that Cassel came into a system like none other so he has to prove his success elsewhere. Rodgers sat behind Favre for 4(?) years and I like the way he looks as a starter. Matt Ryan is still fresh so I'm not on his wagon. And you can argue that Rothlisberger isn't that good a QB because of the defense he has, but this dude has put the team on his back on numerous occasions to win football games. He's the ultimate gamer if you ask me.

---

Just wanted to ask the fair question. I get the point of cassel though as he's not in my top 10 but still thinks he can be a good qb. No college experience and was a plug in the Pats offense.

As to Matt Ryan though, He's got all my props in the world for what he did as a rookie. I'd have to look up Peyton's rookie year but i'd say Matt probably had a better rookie year. He played for a turned around franchise so it wasn't like he stepped in with the Pats offense or something and it was a rookie head coach. For how i did my rankings of qb's moving forward and almost guy's to build a franchise around, i'd definitely have him in top 10... but not in a top 10 of accomplishments per se.

what list midget man?

Chad504

Oh, and you want my top 10 pussy?

1. Drew Brees- cause I'm a motherfricking homer, and he's the shite.
2. Brady- Who's gonna argue that?
3. Manning- Again, team leader, proven track record.
4. Kurt Warner- 3 bowls and a hell of a model american.
5. Big Ben- Tough as fricking nails, a true baller. Plays hurt and plays well. His O line is shite but he still makes it happen
6. McNabb- Similar to Bens style of play. Takes being nicked up a bit worse, but has been to the dance and been to the playoffs numerous times
7-10:
Rivers
Romo
Rodgers
Cutler
Cassel
Ryan


7-10 are toss ups to me. Maybe after Rivers/Romo, but anyway those are some of the guys that are too early to tell, too immature, too inconsistent, you get the point.....

quote:

---

1. Drew Brees- cause I'm a motherfricking homer, and he's the shite.
2. Brady- Who's gonna argue that?
3. Manning- Again, team leader, proven track record.
4. Kurt Warner- 3 bowls and a hell of a model american.
5. Big Ben- Tough as fricking nails, a true baller. Plays hurt and plays well. His O line is shite but he still makes it happen
6. McNabb- Similar to Bens style of play. Takes being nicked up a bit worse, but has been to the dance and been to the playoffs numerous times
7-10:
Rivers
Romo
Rodgers
Cutler
Cassel
Ryan


7-10 are toss ups to me. Maybe after Rivers/Romo, but anyway those are some of the guys that are too early to tell, too immature, too inconsistent, you get the point.....

---

awesome. You got McNabb and Warner in there and i don't bc my list is mainly a list of qb's i'd build a franchise around right now moving forward so youth played and important role. My list wasn't necessarily accomplishment oriented. Even still... McNabb's numbers outside of maybe 1 or 2 seasons has ever been hardly impressive but he is a good player.