re: Friday Music Board Challenge- Jay-Z Defeats Nas in a Close One

Posted by DB10_AFC

South Louisiana

Member since Jun 2012

7080 posts

Posted on 9/2/12 at 4:09 pm to urinetrouble

quote:
Nas has like a one good album per ten year average.

Illmatic
It Was Written
Stillmatic
Hip Hop is Dead
Untitled
Distant Relatives
Life is Good

Guess you are wrong

Posted by DB10_AFC

South Louisiana

Member since Jun 2012

7080 posts

Posted on 9/2/12 at 4:10 pm to D011ahbi11

quote:
Making the greatest album doesnt make him the best

No but being a better MC does.

Posted by LSU Red24

Louisiana

Member since Feb 2007

4769 posts

Posted on 9/2/12 at 4:34 pm to S

I was Made in America last night in Philly. After watching the show he put on, I say Jay for sure. Incredible

Posted by D011ahbi11

Member since Jun 2007

13673 posts

Posted on 9/2/12 at 4:35 pm to DB10_AFC

quote:
Uh I dunno...maybe this year.

Life is good was a great album?

I'll give you good, but far from great.

quote:
Untitled

You must have put this one in there on accident right?

Posted by DB10_AFC

South Louisiana

Member since Jun 2012

7080 posts

Posted on 9/2/12 at 7:14 pm to D011ahbi11

quote:
Life is good was a great album? I'll give you good, but far from great.

Life is Good is one the best hip hop albums of the year. That would make it a great album. Far from great? That is ridiculous. I question your judgement.

quote:

You must have put this one in there on accident right?

Nah it is a good album. Most people and critics would agree. Once again I have to question your judgement.

Posted by D011ahbi11

Member since Jun 2007

13673 posts

Posted on 9/2/12 at 7:47 pm to DB10_AFC

quote:
Most people and critics would agree

Really? I personally dont like pitchfork, but some on here respect it + it's one of the most well known sites in terms of album reviews and they gave it a 3.8 which is terrible.

quote:
Life is Good is one the best hip hop albums of the year. That would make it a great album

Being one of the best of the year does not make it great, sorry. It's possible to go an entire year without a great album.

quote:
I question your judgement.

Dammit, DB10 AFC from tigerdroppings questions my judgement. That just ruins my day.

This post was edited on 9/2/12 at 8:17 pm

2 ...

Posted by S

RIP Wayde

Member since Jan 2007

168271 posts

Posted on 9/2/12 at 9:42 pm to D011ahbi11

jay-z takes it by 3 votes

close one

Posted by DB10_AFC

South Louisiana

Member since Jun 2012

7080 posts

Posted on 9/3/12 at 10:00 am to D011ahbi11

quote:
Really? I personally dont like pitchfork, but some on here respect it + it's one of the most well known sites in terms of album reviews and they gave it a 3.8 which is terrible.

Nas | Album Reviews | Rolling Stone
Nas Untitled Review

Amazon - 4 1/2 stars on 138 reviews

quote:
Being one of the best of the year does not make it great, sorry. It's possible to go an entire year without a great album.

Ok how about it is a great album because it has great music on it.

Nas, Life Is Good | XXL
Nas - Life Is Good Review
Nas: Life Is Good | Album Reviews | Pitchfork

Amazon - 4 1/2 stars on 115 reviews

quote:
Dammit, DB10 AFC from tigerdroppings questions my judgement. That just ruins my day.

I know it probably doesn't bother you. I don't mean it disrespectfully. After reading your post I was just wondering what your background is in hip hop is all.