Started By
Message

IRA to HSA Rollover

Posted on 11/14/26 at 9:39 am
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 9:39 am
Apparently one can do a tax free Trad IRA to HSA rollover with some caveats. This is one and done in a lifetime. The amount cannot exceed the annual HSA contribution amount.

So my question is, is it worth it?

My relevant facts regarding this decision. I am retired. I'm 60 turning 61 in February next year. I worked for two companies in my 32 year career. Neither offered HSA compatible insurance plans. I'm Medicare eligible in February '31. I've been on Obama Care since my retirement in 2020. Open enrollment is now and I'm considering an HSA eligible plan. Can save several 100's per month. I have plenty of assets to handle my expenses for many years. I can rollover $5400 this year with catch up or wait to Jan 1 and do $5500.

What says the board? Yay or Nay?

Investopedia Article Concernig IRA to HSA rollover.
This post was edited on 11/14/26 at 11:28 am
Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger
1st coast
Member since Jan 2008
3468 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 10:36 am to
Interesting, I never heard if this. What's your tax bracket and max out of pocket for each plan?

What's the objective for the HSA? Would you use it for medical expenses as they happen or keep it growing tax free. Tax treatment of HSA for heirs is like a traditional 401k (taxed as income) but no 10 year rule so must be dispersed immediately. Apparently they can't use your old medical receipts either only for expenses within a year of death.
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 11:20 am to
quote:

What's your tax bracket


That varies. My expenses are around 80k/yr. I can massage my tax. I've been doing that for the last six years to get ACA subsidies. Probably around 10 to 15% on average.

quote:

max out of pocket for each plan


I only glanced at a few but it looks like 10-12k per year.

quote:

What's the objective for the HSA? Would you use it for medical expenses as they happen or keep it growing tax free.


I guess to let it grow for the next 5 years while my health is pretty good. So roughly 5 years of tax free growth on $5400 for tax free usage when I get old (older).
This post was edited on 11/14/26 at 11:25 am
Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger
1st coast
Member since Jan 2008
3468 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 12:20 pm to
In 5 years $5500 might grow to $8100 (assuming 8% growth) Tax on that if left in traditional IRA, $800-1200 (10-15% marginal rate).
So, is the additional risk of a high deductible plan worth it for that modest potential tax savings plus any savings due to lower premiums?

If your future marginal rate is higher, growth rate is better the case for HSA improves.

Did you account for state income tax if applicable?
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 12:48 pm to
quote:


In 5 years $5500 might grow to $8100 (assuming 8% growth) Tax on that if left in traditional IRA, $800-1200 (10-15% marginal rate).
So, is the additional risk of a high deductible plan worth it for that modest potential tax savings plus any savings due to lower premiums?

If your future marginal rate is higher, growth rate is better the case for HSA improves.

Did you account for state income tax if applicable?


No state tax, Texas. Honestly my marginal rate will not stay low. In fact I've been advised to open up the purse strings. My Trad IRA is pretty large and I will get hammered when RMD's kick in. So I need to get serious with Roth conversions or charitable giving to avoid inevitable. So sending some to an HSA couldn't hurt but not make much of a difference. I can save around $300 monthly with the HDHP. The OOP in my current plan is $9200 so roughly a wash. I think it can't hurt to move to an HDHP barring I stay relative healthy.
Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger
1st coast
Member since Jan 2008
3468 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 1:21 pm to
You only have 3 years (including 2026) for Roth conversions before age 63 when they may impact IRMAA surcharges at 65. You can always wait and use QCDs to reduce RMDs if necessary. You could also ramp up spending now while you can better enjoy it. Thus, actually spending down the traditional instead of converting just for it to sit.
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 2:32 pm to
quote:

You only have 3 years (including 2026) for Roth conversions before age 63 when they may impact IRMAA surcharges at 65. You can always wait and use QCDs to reduce RMDs if necessary. You could also ramp up spending now while you can better enjoy it. Thus, actually spending down the traditional instead of converting just for it to sit.


Oof, hadn't thought about IRMAA. I'm screwed. Will likely do some conversions and then judicially pull income from the IRA. Like I said I was advised to live more. Now you see why I said my tax will be going up.
Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger
1st coast
Member since Jan 2008
3468 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 2:46 pm to
How much are these dreaded RMDs you're facing? Some cases, they aren't as big a concern as people imagine.
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 3:02 pm to
Over 300,000k
Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger
1st coast
Member since Jan 2008
3468 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 3:24 pm to
Good problem to have, congrats! $300k annual RMD Is 35% single tax bracket plus it's stacked on any other income including 80% of SS. You should have room to convert or spend $200k+ each year and pay less than that future 35% marginal rate. Problem is it's not gonna make a big dent w such a huge traditional balance and still growing.

The HSA plan is least of your worries. I'd pay for some pro advice on tax optimization and drawdown strategies before years end so you dont miss this year. I'm a DIY type but if you are actually facing $300k+ RMDs good advice would be money very well spent. Would help avoid blind spots like IRMAA.
This post was edited on 11/14/26 at 3:30 pm
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 3:38 pm to
quote:

The HSA plan is least of your worries.


Thanks. I didn't know the rollover was possible and HSA was never on my radar. I could still do it just to have some tax free money available without touching my Roth. I have some room in my income calculations to keep my subsidy for 2026 so I'll pull some from the IRA this year. Or I could sell some stock from my taxable brokerage and still stay in the 15% bracket.

You've given me some great insight. I DIY myself but Schwab provides me free consultation if I need it. He's been telling me to get to living so the hit at 75 will not be so bad. I hate paying taxes though.

I get almost 3k of survivor benefits each month so that's an income floor I can't get around.
This post was edited on 11/14/26 at 3:41 pm
Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger
1st coast
Member since Jan 2008
3468 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 3:50 pm to
15% bracket? You mean LTCG rate or 12% bracket? We all have blind spots, I wasnt thinking of ACA subsidies.

Sometimes paying least tax isn't optimal for long term portfolio outcome or spending during lifetime. For instance, I recently concluded that trying to void LTCG and tax harvest in zero LTCG rate first few retirement years was a mistake. I'd have bee better off spending more and/or starting Roth conversions. I also hate paying unnecessary tax but now projecting paying for conversions into 22 and possibly 24% bracket. It's complicated and I should probably hire a pro too.
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 3:59 pm to
15% LTCG. I had and tax accountant do my taxes the year my wife died and she advised to me to start paring down my brokerage through lower gains and IRA through conversions. I didn't listen.
Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger
1st coast
Member since Jan 2008
3468 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 4:15 pm to
Hard to execute tax optimization in those circumstances. (sorry for your loss) I've told my wife to make sure to make a large Roth conversion in the year I pass before she gets hit w widow penalty/single bracket. There's close to zero chance she follows through.

You might consider leaving the taxable brokerage untouched as much as feasible so heirs can get stepped up basis and pay zero LTCG instead of paying 15% yourself. That's one reason I regret zero rate LTCG harvesting. I no longer plan to send from taxable just gonna pass it to heirs tax free alost as good as a Roth just missing 10 yrs of additional tax-free growth once inherited

Spend down or convert the IRA instead. Otherwise, it's gonna be a tax bomb for heirs If they only get 10 yrs to fully draw down. Plus, your RMD issue gets reduced.
Posted by TorchtheFlyingTiger
1st coast
Member since Jan 2008
3468 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 4:28 pm to
Another enjoyable way to avoid LTCG taxes; if your adult kids are in a low bracket (zero LTCG rate) you could gift them appreciated shares to sell and spend tax free. Works for anyone in lower brackets you want to gift to.

I did this last year and got nearly as much joy from stiffing the IRS as gifting to my nephew. Probably gonna make it a recurring thing.
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 4:31 pm to
quote:

You might consider leaving the taxable brokerage untouched as much as feasible so heirs can get stepped up basis and pay zero LTCG instead of paying 15% yourself. That's one reason I regret zero rate LTCG harvesting. I no longer plan to send from taxable just gonna pass it to heirs tax free alost as good as a Roth just missing 10 yrs of additional tax-free growth once inherited


That's been my plan for awhile. I've made one trade in my brokerage in years. I had one lot in my S&P ETF that was at no gain during one of these pull backs we've had recently. I harvested that for spending money through this year.

It's been fun, Gotta run for the tiger's game tonight.
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 4:38 pm to
quote:


Another enjoyable way to avoid LTCG taxes; if your adult kids are in a low bracket (zero LTCG rate) you could gift them appreciated shares to sell and spend tax free. Works for anyone in lower brackets you want to gift to.


I have two sons, early 20's college grads, that are making their way but not earning a lot. I sent my oldest some cash to help him replace a beater we bought him in high school.
Posted by lsu xman
Member since Oct 2006
17102 posts
Posted on 11/14/26 at 8:48 pm to
quote:

Good problem to have, congrats! $300k annual RMD Is 35%


300K total acct or 300K annual RMDs(6mil acct)
Posted by Tiger4life306
Member since Apr 2016
1032 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 12:09 am to
It’s a one time so it’s not really that big of a game changer. I wouldn’t over think it. If you’re facing $300k+ RMDs, why not just do it and then move on
Posted by NBR_Exile
Houston via Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2012
2223 posts
Posted on 11/15/26 at 5:31 am to
quote:


It’s a one time so it’s not really that big of a game changer. I wouldn’t over think it. If you’re facing $300k+ RMDs, why not just do it and then move on


I probably will. Just thought this never discussed option was worthy of some discussion on what is this, oh the Money Talk Board.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

Facebook•X•Instagram