re: Which of the 3 QB’s do you trust the most to

Bro what are you talking about his whole arguement was factual? While you showed a highlight video of a guy who played 5 games in 6 years and said just look at this? It’s true Myles threw for a bunch of yards in those 3 games but it’s also true in those 3 starts he was throwing the ball 44 times a game with a completion percentage of 60% and one of lowest 3rd down conversion rate in the country for that time.

I also agree there’s a lot of romanticizing going on about Myles time here and how those 3 starts looked. When I remember there was very consensus feeling of disappointment among the fan base watching Myles play after finally get his chance short arm throws, look nervous and generally unsure.
We did the same thing with Max last year he won 2 games a couple of months past and that’s all everybody remembers. Not the context around those games.

quote:

---

When I remember there was very consensus feeling of disappointment among the fan base watching Myles play

---

Selective and fake memory. In general people felt satisfied he would be the guy going forward.

Rantards always try to stir up fake drama. No matter who the QB will be, the rantards will cry.

quote:

---

Bro what are you talking about his whole arguement was factual? While you showed a highlight video of a guy who played 5 games in 6 years and said just look at this? It’s true Myles threw for a bunch of yards in those 3 games but it’s also true in those 3 starts he was throwing the ball 44 times a game with a completion percentage of 60% and one of lowest 3rd down conversion rate in the country for that time.

---

Thank you, I feel like I'm taking crazy pills with all of these guys all of sudden wanting to act like Myles is this incredible qb

I’m saying that based on the available game film we have on all three. In the spring game Nuss looked better in those categories. Brennan looked rusty and a little stiff though he did make some nice strike throws but Nuss looked better than Brennan in spring. I’m not arguing that Brennan is the starter or must start, I think the coaches will see who’s the best option and who’s progressed since last we saw all 3. But to argue over what we’ve seen in real games Brennan has put out the best film by far and these silly comments like “he’s a statue” or “he can’t throw under pressure” are obviously untrue since video footage proves otherwise.

It’s not ignorant what Roger is saying is correct. You have an obvious bias ignoring all fact and data available to us.

Your talking about highlight tape though. What does the full game tape of Brennan tell you?

The highlight tape is just a sample, the full story is gaudy numbers, low turnovers and a lot of points with no running game to support him. So the rest of the film is much like the second half of the highlight with Brennan throwing for numbers only surpassed at LSU by Joe Burrow. There was also a post last year that showed only 4 QBs in recent NCAA history, 10-15 years, had better first 3 starts than Brennan.

It’s a very simple contrast, Roger and I are going by what we’ve seen and you’re going by what you think you can predict. Your point is valid about it being 2 years ago (not 3) and down time but you can’t make an absolute judgment based on something like that.

quote:

---

Your talking about highlight tape though. What does the full game tape of Brennan tell you?

---

Compared to whom?