Baseball question: line up for different starting pitchers

Henry is a strike out pitcher. Marceaux pitches to contact. I'm not sure which one you would consider Labas.

It would seem to me that if you are pitching Marceaux you better have a good defense and maybe the same with Labas. With Henry, who is going to get the strike outs, you could go with a more offensive line up.

So the question is, should we have a different line up depending on who the starting pitcher is? An argument for not doing this would be: continuity with the infielders or you find your best 8 and stick with them.