Page 1
Page 1
Started By
Message

At 18 commits, who do we finish with?

Posted on 12/5/17 at 4:49 pm
Posted by GeauxLSU4
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2012
10556 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 4:49 pm
I feel like we aren’t going to sign more than 25 in this class. Assuming we don’t lose any current commits, I think we close with this class:
Pat Surtain Jr.
Terrace Marshall
Badora Traore
Kelvin Joseph
Dominic Livingston
Either James Foster or Justin Rogers
1 of Harold Joiner/Pooka Williams/Justin Watkins
Posted by CP3forMVP
Member since Nov 2010
14909 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 4:52 pm to
I think Watkins is in regardless of those two backs.
Posted by MrWiseGuy
Member since Dec 2009
27421 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 4:55 pm to
quote:

I think Watkins is in regardless of those two backs.


Watkins depends on where Waddle goes
Posted by mdwilkins
Greenwell Springs, LA
Member since Jun 2011
116 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 5:16 pm to
quote:

I feel like we aren’t going to sign more than 25 in this class. Assuming we don’t lose any current commits, I think we close with this class:
Pat Surtain Jr.
Terrace Marshall
Badora Traore
Kelvin Joseph
Dominic Livingston
Either James Foster or Justin Rogers
1 of Harold Joiner/Pooka Williams/Justin Watkins


The new rules limit everyone to a max of 25.
I would drop Dominic Livingston (we have a ton of DT committed).
I would take Justin Watkins or another similar slot receiver with that scholarship. Particularly since we did not have enough WR to run 4 wide sets this year. ;-)
I would prefer Anthony "Pooka" Williams if he can get grades. He has dominated the 5A playoffs. And we are in good position next year for running backs if he falls through. The two RB commits would get us through the next year.
Posted by Brunedog
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2014
6483 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 5:30 pm to
Anthony cook may also land in this class and hearing travez Moore still has grades problem something to keep an eye on
Posted by Drillingman
Member since Feb 2015
1051 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 5:39 pm to

All these Great receivers in state..... why can’t we pull in the haul ?

We could set up ourselves..... will we lose guys to Kansas, TCU, etc ???

That’s bullshite !!!!!!
Posted by cajunduby
C-Bus
Member since Nov 2012
2248 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 5:47 pm to
quote:

travez Moore still has grades problem 


What the frick. I never understood this. Get a fricking tutor, get i the books and off Twitter.
Posted by GeauxLSU4
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2012
10556 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 6:13 pm to
If we land Marshall, Jones, Jenkins, and Watkins that will be a really good class. Chase and Jason had their chance to be in this class.
Posted by Sterling Archer
Austin
Member since Aug 2012
7318 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 6:20 pm to
Are we recruiting any other OL? I see we have only 3 committed.

I don't know anything about Dare Rosenthal other than his height at 6'7. Is he a possible switch from DT to OT?

Seems like we should have add at least one more in addition to Badora.
Posted by LsuTool
Member since Oct 2009
34848 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 6:21 pm to
Wise, drop some knowledge on these fools. How we looking to finish up?
Posted by rmnldr
Member since Oct 2013
38231 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 7:08 pm to
Patrick Surtain
Badara Traore
Kelvin Joseph
James Foster
Terrace Marshall
Pooka Williams (as a slot receiver)
Harold Joiner
Posted by lilmoonlsu
Member since Jan 2015
671 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 7:27 pm to
This would give us a composite score of 273.93. This would easily put us in the top 10. With the monster 2019 class we gonna ride
Posted by lsusportsman2
Member since Oct 2007
27232 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 7:35 pm to
quote:

I don't know anything about Dare Rosenthal other than his height at 6'7. Is he a possible switch from DT to OT?


I trust that the coaches will put him wherever they think is best. I do believe that they should consider the switch to OT though. He's got the size and athleticism there, but who knows?

Just a guess, but I think they finish with:

Surtain
Marshall
Watkins
Joseph
Traore
Joiner
Foster or Rogers, most likely Foster.
Beal
Cook, but I'm hesitant about this one.

I do think we sign over 25, most likely 27, so assuming we keep the 18 we already have, we can sign about 9 more. I would love to see Chase and Jason signed in this class too, but I think that bridge is already burned. Livingston will likely be apart of this class too. I really really want Cook though. This to me is the only name I mentioned that could choose elsewhere. This would be a great finish regardless.
This post was edited on 12/5/17 at 7:43 pm
Posted by LesnarF5
Member since Apr 2015
9219 posts
Posted on 12/5/17 at 10:19 pm to
I just don't see Beal TE in this class. Too many bigger fish IMO. If grades work out Pooka needs to be in this class, way too much talent and ways he can contribute not to have. I'd go with WR Marshall, Watkins then Athlete Pooka. DB's Joseph, Surtain maybe Cook then 1 QB. Not a knock but we really don't need NG Livingston in this class.
This post was edited on 12/5/17 at 10:23 pm
Posted by alumni95
Member since Jun 2004
7587 posts
Posted on 12/6/17 at 3:36 am to
Not signing over 25.

quote:

Schools used to be able to take more than 25 signees in a class with the loophole being they could count early enrollees to the previous signing class.

According to a college coach we spoke to, that loophole is no longer in effect meaning there is a hard cap at no more than 25 signees in each given class, provided a school can sign that many prospects and not go over the NCAA mandated 85-person scholarship limit.

Under the old rule, LSU would be able to sign 27 players in the 2018 class. However, 25 is the number that Ed Orgeron and his staff must juggle.


LINK - Recruiting rules to know (from Sonny)

I suppose the remaining question is how would the JUCO guys be counted. If they (Traore/Lewis) could be “backcounted,” then I suppose we would be at 27 by taking a full allotment of 25 HS signees.
This post was edited on 12/6/17 at 3:51 am
Posted by wheelz007
Denham Springs, LA
Member since Jan 2010
3367 posts
Posted on 12/6/17 at 8:38 am to
IF the JUCO guys are considered "transfers", then they do NOT count against the 25. They count against the 85 limit.

Posted by MajorTiger
Baton Rouge
Member since May 2011
189 posts
Posted on 12/6/17 at 8:44 am to
Pat Surtain Jr.
Terrace Marshall
Badora Traore
Kelvin Joseph
Pooka Williams
Justin Watkins
Michael Williams

This is our most likely finish IMO (assuming we don't lose one of our current commits). Seems that Pooka is trending over Joiner and it doesn't seem to me that Foster is a huge priority (for whatever reason). The big question to me is where Beal would fit in this picture. Not sure who he would replace off that list.
This post was edited on 12/6/17 at 8:46 am
Posted by Cadello
Eunice
Member since Dec 2007
47802 posts
Posted on 12/6/17 at 12:19 pm to
Dream finish:
Surtain Jr.
Joseph
Cook
Traore
Marshall
Joiner
Rogers
Watkins
Pooka

Out of the 18 commits I think we lose 1 or 2 by signing day.
This post was edited on 12/6/17 at 12:22 pm
Posted by ShreveportTiger1987
Shreveport
Member since Jan 2014
5494 posts
Posted on 12/6/17 at 12:56 pm to
Everyone
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram